Property Rules,Liability Rules and Unjust Enrichment Rules:An Efficiency Comparison Between Tort Law and Unjust Enrichment Law in Unauthorized Disposition Cases

Liu Kaixiang,Xue Qiming

2012-01-01

Abstract:In the case of unauthorized disposition,German law and American law both require that the unauthorized disposition person return the disposal income to the obligee as " unjust enrichment ".The justification of the rule neither can be explained with the traditional result-oriented approach of law and economics,nor has direct relevance to the " transaction costs ".In fact,its real justification lies in the allocation of the property with the chances of profiting from the transactions of subject matter,especially clarifies the property which can increase chances for small probability profit.By contrast,tort damages rules usually only realize the property allocation of transaction profiting chances which are lower than objective market price,but cannot deal with the property unclarity and rent dissipation problems of increasing chances for small probability profit.