Do short-term investors in housing market do good and do well? Evidence from Presale Market in Singapore

Yuming Fu,Wenlan Qian

2010-01-01

Abstract:The presale market for residential properties in Singapore attracts more short-term investors due to the relatively low cost for short-term speculation in forward sale contracts. By definition the short-term investors trade for speculative gains from price appreciation rather than for income returns, and they are identified in our study as those who sell their investment in forward contracts on or before the property delivery. Evidence on the role of short-term speculators in financial markets is mixed. To evaluate whether those short-term investors are better informed than long-term investors in the real estate market, we examine the short-term investment activities in three ways. First, we evaluate the impact of the short-term investment activity level on the price dynamics of forward contract trading across new residential development projects. Second, we evaluate the holding-period performance of the short-term investors against the market. Third, we examine the market entry behavior of the short-term investors, testing the momentum trading propensity (Hong and Stein, 1999). Our empirical analysis, on the one hand, finds evidence suggesting that not all short-term speculators are informed (regarding future demand shocks for individual projects) and on average they underperform the market (thus adding noises to market price discovery and exacerbating project price volatility). On the other hand, participation of short-term investors appears to enhance the marketing of the projects (by generating more search effort) and hence raise the long-term value of the projects.