Clinical outcomes of the full-thickness chondral defects repair in the knee with arthroscopic microfracture and Pridie drilling technique

WANG Yan-ming,YU Jia-kuo,AO Ying-fang,WANG Jian-quan,CUI Guo-qing,HU Yue-lin,ZHANG Ji-ying,FU Xin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-134X.2010.06.003

2010-01-01

Abstract:Objective To compare the clinical effects of arthroscopic microfracture with Pridie drilling for the repair of fullthickness chondral defects in the knee.Methods 72 patients(80 knees) who suffered from full-thickness articular cartilage defects were randomly divided into microfracture group and Pridie drilling group from January 2006 to December 2009.36 cases(40 knees) in the microfracture group had received the treatment with arthroscopic microfracture technique,the other 36 cases(40 knees) in the Pridie drilling group had received the treatment with arthroscopic Pridie drilling technique.All the patients were followed up for an average of(39.0 ± 13.7) months(range:11-59 months).Lysholm score was used for evaluation before and after the operation for both groups.Results Both procedures resulted in a significant improvement compared to the situation before the operation.In microfracture group,23 cases showed excellent result(63.9%),11 cases were good result(30.6%),and two cases had bad result(5.5%).The total effective rate of clinical outcome was94.5%.The mean Lysholm score improved from(38.1 ±14.9) to(89.4 ± 12.3)(P < 0.01).There was significant improvement of knee function scores between preoperation and postoperation group(P < 0.01).In Pridie drilling group,15 cases showed excellent result(41.7%),16 cases were good result(44.4%),and five cases had bad result(13.9%).The total effective rate of clinical outcome was 86.1%.Lysholm score improved from(36.7 ± 12.8) to(80.2 ±9.5)(P<0.01).Significant knee function scores improvement was also found postoperatively in this group(P<0.01).No significant difference was noticed between microfracture and Pridie drilling for treatment of full-thickness articular chondral defects in the knee(P > 0.05).Conclusions Both microfracture and Pridie drilling techniques had good clinical results in treatment of the fullthickness chondral defects in the knee.There was no significant difference in the clinical outcomes between the two arthroscopic techniques but the microfracture group showed more knee function scores improvement.