A Comparative Study of Cognitive and Generative Constructional Theories:With Special Reference to Construction Grammar and First Phase Syntax

HU Xuhui
2012-01-01
Abstract:This paper provides a comparative study of the two constructional theories,i.e.Construction Grammar and First Phase Syntax,which are the representative constructional theories of the cognitive and generative linguistic schools respectively.The common ground of the two theories lies in two aspects:(1) the shared semantic and syntactic event-decomposition tradition;(2) the similar direct theoretical motivation.Four aspects of distinctive differences are involved:(1) the types and meaning of constructions;(2) the relationship between verbs and constructions;(3) the syntactic operation beyond argument structure level;(4) views on language.Based on the discussion of the differences,this paper explores the advantages and disadvantages of both theories,and shows that the two approaches are closer to each other than initially assumed.Suggestions about bridging the gap between the two approaches are also provided at each point of difference.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?