Reach-scale Riparian Comprehensive Assessment for Suzhou Creek, Shanghai

WANG Dongdong,YANG Kai,CHE Yue,L(U) Yongpeng

2010-01-01

Abstract:Natural characteristics of riparian zones in China are under destruction and degradation because of urbanization,and this brings a series of environmental problems.Riparian comprehensive assessment is the significant component of riparian zone remediation planning and sustainable management.Reach scale as the smallest scale of riparian comprehensive assessment study has the uniform functional characteristics and homogeneous advantage.Therefore,reach-scale riparian comprehensive assessment is more maneuverable and unified in comprehensive assessment and comparative analysis.The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the current situation of riparian zone and make a comparative analysis among multi-factors in different dimensions.Thus,a method based on riparian comprehensive situation index(RCSI)was proposed for the reach-scale riparian comprehensive assessment.The proposed method included 5 steps.Firstly,listing indexes relevant to riparian zone from the correlated studies;moreover,developing the reach-scale riparian comprehensive assessment index system,and the system,including 4 first-grade indexes and 23 second-grade indexes,is based on horizontal structure of riparian zone(including waterfront zone,revetment zone,buffer zone and nearshore zone)and principles of index selection;furthermore,establishing standards for assessing sub-factors according to field characteristics and experts preferences;fourthly,weighting the indexes and ranking the comprehensive situation of riparian zone to 5 grades(best,better,common,worse and worst)by RCSI;finally,putting forward strategies for adaptive riparian planning and management.A case study implementing the method was performed on riparian zones of Suzhou Creek in Shanghai,whose natural characteristics are under signi?cant destruction and degradation due to rapid urbanization.43 reaches were selected as the assessment units on the main stream of Suzhou Creek.The results show that:(i)The riparian comprehensive situation of Suzhou Creek is in the poor grade with RCSI distributing from 3.79 to 25.03,and no reach is in the best grade,and 69.8% reaches belongs to worse or worst grade;(ii)River channelization and revetment hardening of Suzhou Creek result in more than 85% reaches of the waterfront and revetment zone status belonging to worse or worst grade,the width of waterfront zone and type of revetment are the key factors to the grade;(iii)Though 72.1% reaches of the buffer zone status belongs to common or better,irrational vegetation structure and single species problems are still remained;(iv)Rapid urbanization makes more than 50% reaches of the nearshore zone status belonging to worse or worst grade,and impervious area ratio and facilities richness degree are the crucial factors to the grade;(v)The results of analysis of variance(ANOVA)reveal that human activity intensity and urbanization are the key forces to cause RCSI and most of other indexes having significant differences in reach location and land use types,while waterfront zone width,revetment slope,erosion degree,α diversity index and longitudinal connectivity have no significant differences;(vi)The results of case study suggest that the proposed method can be used to carry efficiently out the reach-scale riparian comprehensive assessment.What's more,the results of case study may help local authorities better understand the comprehensive situation of riparian zone,and put forward improved strategies for sustainable riparian planning and adaptive management which can better balance riparian development and ecological conservation.