Abstract:This paper revises the conceptualization of party system institutionalization, as defined in Mainwaring and Scully’s (1995) groundbreaking work. Regarding the rules of aggregation involved in conceptual structure, my argument resonates with Goertz and Mahoney’s (2012) identification of two different “cultures” in contemporary social science. They understand one culture as building what Goertz calls “family resemblance” concepts, usually measured through a latent variable approach. The other culture understands concepts as structured in terms of “necessary and sufficient” elements, which can then be measured using an ontological approach. I claim that party system institutionalization has an implicit “family resemblance” structure and show that conceptual structure to be empirically and theoretically inadequate. In its current form, the concept of party system institutionalization also suffers from deficiencies when it comes to indicator validity and aggregation, as per (Munck and Verkulien, Comp Polit Stud 35(1):5–34, 2002) criteria. Problems of validity are caused by analysts’ frequent reliance on a single indicator for operationalizing the concept. Problems of aggregation and conceptual structure arise from inconsistencies between the implicit theoretical assumption that party system institutionalization is conceptually linear and non-linear patterns that are not only theoretically plausible but also empirically observable in a large set of cases. Therefore, this paper advocates revising the concept and the way it is currently applied in the comparative party system literature. Such revision will permit better understanding of both the characteristics and dynamic evolution of party systems.

The Institutional Origins of One-Party Regimes's Collapse——Review and Reconstruction

Institutional Rebound: Why Reforming China's State-Owned Enterprises is So Difficult

From party cartel to one-party dominance. The case of institutional failure

Party System Institutionalization: Do We Need a New Concept?

Comparative Analysis of Foreign Long-term Ruling Parties——Their Ruling Methods,Difficulties and Transformation

Democracy and the Entanglement of Political Parties and the State: Party–State Relations in 20th-Century France, Italy, and Germany

Patterns of one-party dominance in African democracies : how one-party dominant systems endure and decline

The Party and the People: Revolutionary and Postrevolutionary Politics in China and Vietnam

Party Adaptation and the Prospects for Democratization in Authoritarian China

Party System and Chinese Democracy:A Perspective of Political Science

Party Politics in Socialist Countries: One Hundred Years of Exploration

The Model of Political Parties and the Limits of Government Innovation——A Comparative Analysis

A Study of Organizational Transition of the Ruling Party from the Perspective of Social Governance

The Crisis of Representativeness and Post-Party Politics*

The Institutional Factors for the CPSU's Loss of Political Power

Party Origins, Party Infrastructural Strength, and Governance Outcomes

All Power to the Party! the Sources of Ruling Party Strength in Authoritarian Regimes

Some Thoughts about the Ruling Party's Ideal of Governance in the Course of Modernization

Party Politics and Party Principle of Journalism:The Theoretical Reflection on the Journalism History of PRC over 60 Years

Party as Political Organization:Generating or Impeding Political Leadership?——A Comparative Study on China,Japan and Singapore

Party Building as Institutional Bricolage: Asserting Authority at the Business Frontier