Radical Turnover or Gradual Turnover？ Empirical Study of Founder Turnover on Firm Performance in China
梅琳,贺小刚,李婧
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19616/j.cnki.bmj.2012.01.009
2012-01-01
Abstract:New start-up is considered as the extension of entrepreneurship （Chandler and Jansen, 1992）, and the founder is in the center stage of founding process. Some scholars pay much attention on the roles of founder and founding team on firm performance （Sandberg and Hofer, 1987; Cooper and Bruno, 1997; Chrisman et al. , 1998; Lechler, 2001; Casson, 2000; He and Yu, 2008）. But these literatures are mainly concerned on the indi- vidual characteristics of founders, cognitive level （McClelland, 1961; Forbes, 1999）, or team capital （Cooper and Bruno, 1997; Lechler, 2001 ; Casson, 2000;He and Yu, 2008）, which frequently ascribe a rather static role to the founder in his start-up company. In fact, it is a frequently observed phenomenon that the founders do not keep their job positions in new ventures. New ventures are often founded by entrepreneurs interested in the initial development of the product or market, but who have very limited managerial interests or capacities （ Willard, Krueger, and Feeser, 1992）. As the venture becomes more established these entrepreneurs may be forced to focus more closely on general management tasks-tasks in which they may have no interest or natural proclivity. The life-cycle theory vividly illustrates the reasons of founder＇ s eventual turnover （ Hambrick and FuKutomi, 1991 ）, when new ventures outgrow the managerial capabilities of the founder. Although many literatures focus on the reasons of top managers＇ turnover, especially CEOs＇ turnover, and the impacts on firms＇ growth, few scholars acutely shed light on the phenomenon of founder turnover-a situation in which entrepreneurs decide to leave their initially taken job position. In general, little is known about the impact of founder departure on firm performance and get no consistent conclusions （Johnson et al. , 1985 ;Adams et al. , 2005 ;Morcket al. ,1988; Anderson and Reeb, 2003; Adams et al. , 2009）. Burkhart et al. （2003） proposed that founders have different choices when facing departure. Based on first-hand data in China, He et al. （2007） summarized the five types of founders＇ turnover as completely leaving, changing into weak shareholder, changing into weak staff, changing into a consultant for the decision makers and operating behind the scenes. No matter what type of founder＇ s turnover, its impact on enterprise performance cannot be ignored. Actually, different ways of founder departure tend to perform differently. We note a founder in a family firm as the one who creates the enterprise and is responsible for the firm＇ s early growth, and classified ways of founder departure into radical turnover and gradual turnover from the perspective of management power transferring. Based on the panel data of Chinese listed family-owned firms from 2001 to 2005, this study explores the different effects of radical turnover and gradual turnover on firm performance, and the moderating effects of market environment and power transformation. Following results are obtained. First, gradual turnover of founder has a significant positive effect on firm performance comparing with radical turnover. Therefore, founders may choose an appropriate way of leaving for firm growth. Second, the effects of founder turnover have been moderated by institutional environment. Regarding to this, we disclose that gradual turnover of founder is more effective for performance when market environment is poor. Furthermore, the moderation effect of power transformation is also important. The effect of founder＇ gradual departure on firm performance is stronger when founder＇ s original power is divided by more than one successor, while the effect is weaker when keeping the original mode. Previously literature on founder turnover focus mostly on US firms, relatively limited attention has been paid to developing countries. Particularly, there is no analysis of the founder turnover-growth relationship for listed firms in China. Our research expands the understanding of the founder departure in the transition economics.