Implant failure of clavicular fracture:analysis and treatment
Hao Zhang,Qianyun He,Guangchao Wang,Dake Tong,Hao Tang,Chen Ding,Kang Liu,Fang Ji
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2016.02.004
2016-01-01
Abstract:Background Clavicluar fracture is a common fracture type,accounting for 5.98%of all the fractures.In the past we used to treat this fracture with non-surgical treatment,such as clavicle belt,figure of "8" bandage,clinical observation found that non-operative therapy was often accompanied by long time immobilization,more complications and it influences the life quality of patients.At present,adult clavicular fractures with large displacement are mostly advocated for surgery.However,due to technical errors or improper application of internal fixation,failure of internal fixation occurred occasionally.In this study,we analyzed the reasons for the failure of internal fixation in 18 cases with clavicular fractures admitted to our hospital from 2007 to 2012 and discussed possible treatment methods.Methods General information:Of the total 18 cases,1 6 were followed up,with 1 1 males and 5 females,aged from 22-67 years old,and the average age was 5 1.7 years old. According to the classification of Craig,there were 13 cases with type A fractures (clavicle shaft 1/5),3 cases with type B (lateral 1/5 of clavicle)fractures,12 cases were comminuted fractures and 4 cases were simple fractures.According to the causes of fracture,there are 9 cases with traffic accident injuries and 6 cases with fall injuries,1 case with other injuries,1 5 cases were closed fractures,and 1 case was open fracture.Implant failures occurred at 2-12 months (mean 4.4 months) after operation.There were 14 cases with plate fixation failure and 2 cases with kirschner wire or steel wire fixation failure.Treatment methods:Twelve cases accepted re-operation,and implants were removed after fracture healing in 4 cases.For the patients who received second operation,surgeries were performed in the beach chair position with brachial plexus anesthesia.We chose longer plates,3-4 screws in each end of the fracture,and bone graft were performed in patients with bone defect.In four cases with plate broken and minor displacement,shoulder elbow belts were used to protect fracture,X-ray film were taken regularly,and implants were removed after primary bony healing. Results We analyzed the causes for internal fixation failures:(1)periosteum was stripped extensively in order to have an anatomical reduction;(2 )plate was too short;(3 )plate was precontoured repeatedly;(4)too many screws were used,especially in fracture site;(5)inappropriate wire cerclarge. The above reasons occurred in the failures of 13 cases. One case was for early weight-bearing activities,1 case for postoperative trauma and 1 case for unknown reason.Of the total 1 6 cases,12 cases received reoperation,4 cases accepted removal of implants after fracture healing,and all the patients achieved bone healing.During the follow-ups after the treatment,mild pain at the fracture area was observed in 2 cases,mild clavicle deformity was in 2 cases and reduced shoulder ROM was in 2 cases.Conclusions Iatrogenic factors are the main causes for the failure of internal fixation of clavicular fracture.Most of the reasons for internal fixation failure are complex,and specific therapy should be taken according to the type of fracture,the choice of internal fixation,medical expenses and other individual factors.