Abstract:For the purpose of sediment quality assessment, the prediction of toxicity risk-levels for aquatic organisms based on simple environmental measurements is desirable. One commonly used approach is the comparison of total contaminant concentrations with corresponding water and sediment quality guideline values, serving as a Line of Evidence (LoE) based on chemistry-toxicity effects relationships. However, the accuracy of toxicity predictions can be improved by considering the factors that modify contaminant bioavailability . In this study we used paired chemistry-ecotoxicity data sets for sediments to evaluate the improvement in toxicity risk predictions using bioavailability-modified guidelines. The sediments were predominantly contaminated with metals, and measurements of sediment particle size, total organic carbon (TOC) and acid volatile sulfide (AVS) were used to modify hazard quotients (HQ). To further assess the predictive efficacy of the bioavailability-modified guideline models, sediments with differing contamination levels were tested for toxicity to a benthic amphipod's reproduction. To account for differences between laboratory exposure and field exposure scenarios, where the latter creates greater dilution, both static-renewal and flow-through test procedures were employed, and flow-through resulted in lower dissolved metal concentrations in the overlying waters. We also investigated how lower AVS concentration by oxidation modified the toxicity. This study reaffirmed that consideration of factors that influence contaminant bioavailability improves toxicity risk predictions, however the improvements may be modest. The sediment particle size data had the greatest influence on the modified HQ, indicating that higher percentage of fine particle size (<63 μm) contributed most to a lower predicted toxicity. The comparison of the static-renewal and flow-through test results continue to raise important questions about the relevance of static or static-renewal toxicity test results for risk assessment decisions, as both these test designs may cause unrealistically high contributions of dissolved metals in overlying waters to toxicity. Overall, this study underscores the value of incorporating outcomes from simple and routine sediment analysis (e.g., particle size, TOC, and consideration of AVS) to enhance the predictive efficacy of toxicity risk assessments in the context of sediment quality risk assessment.

Methods for Sediment Toxicity Evaluation

Sediment Quality Triad and Its Application in Coastal Ecosystems in Recent Years

Identifying the causes of sediment-associated toxicity in urban waterways in South China: Incorporating bioavailabillity-based measurements into whole-sediment toxicity identification evaluation.

Review of Approaches for Deriving Sediment Quality Guidelines

Ecological Risk Assessment Methodology of Toxic Pollutants in Surface Water and Sediments:A Review

Improving toxicity prediction of metal-contaminated sediments by incorporating sediment properties

Sediment Toxicity Tests: A Critical Review of Their use in Environmental Regulations

Risk assessment for sediment associated heavy metals using sediment quality guidelines modified by sediment properties

Sediment quality guidelines: challenges and opportunities for improving sediment management

Development of Identification of Key Toxicants in the Pore Water

Evaluation of Cytotoxicity, Genotoxicity and Teratogenicity of Marine Sediments from Qingdao Coastal Areas Using in Vitro Fish Cell Assay, Comet Assay and Zebrafish Embryo Test.

Deriving freshwater sediment quality guidelines of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons using method of species sensitivity distribution and application for risk assessment

Diagnosis of complex mixture toxicity in sediments: Application of toxicity identification evaluation (TIE) and effect-directed analysis (EDA)

Evaluation Methods for Assessing Effectiveness of in Situ Remediation of Soil and Sediment Contaminated with Organic Pollutants and Heavy Metals

Effect-Directed Analysis of Toxicants in Sediment with Combined Passive Dosing and in Vivo Toxicity Testing.

Assessment of Metal Toxicity and Development of Sediment Quality Guidelines Using the Equilibrium Partitioning Model for the Three Gorges Reservoir, China.

Identifying Sediment-Associated Toxicity in Rivers Affected by Multiple Pollutants from the Contaminant Bioavailability.

Toxic effects of heavy metals on the freshwater benthic organisms in sediments and research on quality guidelines in Poyang Lake, China

Ecotoxicological Bioassays of Sediment Leachates in a River Bed Flanked by Decommissioned Pesticide Plants in Nantong City, East China

Assessing Metal Toxicity in Sediments Using the Equilibrium Partitioning Model and Empirical Sediment Quality Guidelines: a Case Study in the Nearshore Zone of the Bohai Sea, China.

Impact of River Water-Sediment Conditions on Water-Quality Assessment