Abstract:<p class="a-plus-plus">We explore how "international organizations" have been conceptualized and operationalized in the field of International Relations (IR), identify an important gap between the two, and demonstrate how this shapes our understanding of world politics. Traditionally, we show, IR has embraced a broad conception of international organizations (IOs) that appreciates variation in design. However, the literature has largely coalesced around a measurement standard that reflects the characteristics of major postwar IOs. Prevailing measures, therefore, mainly count formal IOs—bodies founded with legally binding agreements—and omit informal IOs, which are founded with non-binding instruments. We argue that this produces a disconnect between theory and empirical evidence used in the field, since scholars frequently make arguments about IOs in general but draw inferences from formal IOs only. After reviewing how this disconnect has emerged, we use an original dataset on state membership in 260 informal IOs to reanalyze a number of important studies, showing heterogeneous effects for subtypes of IOs that conflict with existing theories to varying degrees. These differences imply that formal and informal IOs have different effects and that existing findings in the field are partly artifacts of the specific way IO variables have been operationalized by scholars. Based on this, we offer recommendations for how to improve research practices moving forward.</p>

Theories and Explanations in IR Studies

Grand Theories of International Relations and the Synthetic Explanation Model

The Critical Theories in IR Studies: Origins, Ideas, and Influences

Theorization of International Relations Theory

Language and International Relations: A New Framework for Political Analysis

Theories,Strategies,and Policies of International Relations

Historical Understandings on International Relations

Explaining the Normative Patterns of International Relations: Theories of International Regimes and the Theoretical Synthesis

Approaches and Paradigms in International Relations Studies

A Theory of International Organization

Micro Research Method for System Theory of International Relations

International Systems and Domestic Politics: Linking Complex Theories with Empirical Models in International Relations

Understand Meanings: Theory, Discourse and International Relations

From Paradigms to Research Programs: The Structure of IR Theory

In Search of Chinese International Relations Theory: a Mission Impossible?

On the Internal and External Debates of Positivist IR Research

International Relations Studies and the Method of Hermeneutics

How to Understand International Systems

Metaphor and Construction of IR Theory

Development of IR Theoretical Studies in the United States:On the Basis of Articles in International Organization and International Studies Quarterly

Analyzing international organizations: How the concepts we use affect the answers we get