Abstract:Collective forests have long played an important economic, cultural and social role in the remote mountainous areas of China, especially before the Open and Reform Period. However, the centrist legal framework for managing and utilizing the collective forests was not sufficiently well developed to meet the demands of all community members, which led to largely unfettered overuse and illegal logging. This "tragedy of the commons" meant that the traditional human-forest connections that were so important in these areas gradually collapsed, to be replaced by self-interest. This situation informed a period of property rights reform in which steps were taken to introduce a form of legal pluralism that could improve both security of tenure and forest management. Using a study of Hongtian Village in Southern China, where forest tenure reform started, we argue that pluralist collective action is essential in order to identify grass-root solutions to the management of the forest commons. This involves the use rights for collective forests being separated from those of ownership, with the former distributed to households, according to their own, local, rules. While this new pluralist approach to forest tenure fostered renewed confidence in the potential for collective forestry to underpin community prosperity, the paper goes on to show how renewed top-down intervention, this time to promote a more ecological approach to forest management, has once again undermined the significance of people-forest relationships. We conclude by arguing that forests are very much at the frontier of property rights reform in China, because their effective governance depends utterly upon ensuring a plural approach to regulation that central authorities are currently unwilling to legitimate.

Forest Property Right Reform - How to Make the Dual Nature Forest Property Rights Run Parallel

Usufruct of Forest in Continental Legal Family and Reform of Management Right of Forest in China

An Analysis on the Nature of Chinese Land Property Rights and Its Trajectory of Reform

Reconstruction of China’s Farmland Rights System Based on the ‘trifurcation of Land Rights’ Reform

Collective Forests and the Community at the Legal Frontier of Property Rights Reforms in China

Deliberating How to Resolve the Major Challenges Facing China'S Forest Tenure Reform and Institutional Change

China's Forest Tenure Reform and Institutional Change at a Crossroads

Understanding of a Few Basic Legal Systems of Collective Forest Property Reformation

Research on the Issues and countermeasures of Forest Resources Property Right System in China

On the System of Forest Ownership by Means of the Law Relating to Rights over Things

Present Situations of the Reform of Leased Collective Forest Property Right

Misreading and Rational Cognition of Forest Right

Path Choice for the Reform of Land Property and Its Transfer Policies

Effect of Land Property Rights on Forest Resources in Southern China

Study of the Support of Government Function and Policy in the Reform of State-Owned Forestry Property System

Incentivizing Household Forest Management in China's Forest Reform: Limitations to Rights-Based Approaches in Southwest China

On the Realistic Predicament and System Perfection of the Transactions of Collective Forestland under the Land Security Function

Forestland Reform in China: What do the Farmers Want? A Choice Experiment on Farmers' Property Rights Preferences

Reform in Property Right for Rational Utilization of Water Resources and Balanced Water Supply

Forest Tenure Reform in China: A Choice Experiment on Farmers' Property Rights Preferences

Analysis on the Performance of Collective Forest Tenure Reform