Abstract:Assertions have been the de facto collateral for simulation-based and formal verification of hardware designs for over a decade. The quality of hardware verification, \ie, detection and diagnosis of corner-case design bugs, is critically dependent on the quality of the assertions. There has been a considerable amount of research leveraging a blend of data-driven statistical analysis and static analysis to generate high-quality assertions from hardware design source code and design execution trace data. Despite such concerted effort, all prior research struggles to scale to industrial-scale large designs, generates too many low-quality assertions, often fails to capture subtle and non-trivial design functionality, and does not produce any easy-to-comprehend explanations of the generated assertions to understand assertions' suitability to different downstream validation tasks. Recently, with the advent of Large-Language Models (LLMs), there has been a widespread effort to leverage prompt engineering to generate assertions. However, there is little effort to quantitatively establish the effectiveness and suitability of various LLMs for assertion generation. In this paper, we present AssertionBench, a novel benchmark to evaluate LLMs' effectiveness for assertion generation quantitatively. AssertioBench contains 100 curated Verilog hardware designs from OpenCores and formally verified assertions for each design generated from GoldMine and HARM. We use AssertionBench to compare state-of-the-art LLMs to assess their effectiveness in inferring functionally correct assertions for hardware designs. Our experiments demonstrate how LLMs perform relative to each other, the benefits of using more in-context exemplars in generating a higher fraction of functionally correct assertions, and the significant room for improvement for LLM-based assertion generators.

Application of SVA in Hardware functional verification

A System Verification Environment for Mixed-Signal SOC Design Based on IP Bus

An SVA Hardware Monitor with Off-Line Replay

LAAG-RV: LLM Assisted Assertion Generation for RTL Design Verification

Automatic High-quality Verilog Assertion Generation through Subtask-Focused Fine-Tuned LLMs and Iterative Prompting

OSVAuto: semi-automatic verifier for functional specifications of operating systems

Generative AI Assertions in UVM-Based System Verilog Functional Verification

AssertLLM: Generating and Evaluating Hardware Verification Assertions from Design Specifications via Multi-LLMs

ChIRAAG: ChatGPT Informed Rapid and Automated Assertion Generation

Assertion Based Functional Verification of March Algorithm Based MBIST Controller

An assertion-based verification method for SystemC TLM

FVEval: Understanding Language Model Capabilities in Formal Verification of Digital Hardware

AssertLLM: Generating Hardware Verification Assertions from Design Specifications via Multi-LLMs

VST-A: A Foundationally Sound Annotation Verifier

AssertionBench: A Benchmark to Evaluate Large-Language Models for Assertion Generation

Integrating Formal Verification and Simulation-based Assertion Checking in a Corroborative V&V Process

Assertion Recommendation for Formal Program Verification.

A System-Level SOC Verification Method Based on Hardware Accelerator

A Formal Verification Method for the SOPC Software

The FCU Verification Platform Based on VMM