Abstract:Housing reconstruction is the top priority after the occurrence of natural hazards. The manner of providing housing not only matters to community recovery but also determines whether reconstruction is sustainable, particularly in rural areas in developing countries. Developing concentrated rural settlements (CRS) is sustainable and resilient in post-disaster reconstruction. However, such development has been reported in few studies before the reconstruction that followed the Sichuan Earthquake on May 12, 2008. CRS have been successfully implemented in several villages in Dujiangyan City, China through a policy of exchanging rural residential land. CRS were delivered in two different approaches, namely, unified planning/self-reconstruction and unified planning/unified–reconstruction. However, these two approaches have not been thoroughly investigated in previous studies. Therefore, the reasons for adopting the two different approaches and which approach is more effective remain unknown. The current study aims to fill in this research gap by comparing the two approaches in the aspects of social–natural basis, trigger event, participants, principles, revenue allocation, process, and implementation outcome involving four study cases in Dujiangyan City. Relevant information was collected through content analysis and interviews. The comparison indicated that neither approach is ideal. Each approach should first satisfy specific requirements to ensure the reconstruction's sustainability. A roadmap to deliver CRS during post-disaster reconstruction has been provided based on the comparison. The findings of this study can facilitate the decision-making process of local governments regarding CRS development during post-disaster reconstruction.

Discussion on the Planning of Buliding Farmhouse in Progress of Post-Quake Reconstruction

Discussing Design Strategy and Promotion Mechanism of Farmers Residential Paradigm in Post-disaster Deconstruction:Xiayuan Village Jiandi Shifang as an example

Application of Modern Bamboo Struture to Reconstruction after Wenchuan Earthguake

Remaking of the Spiritual Homeland of the Post-Quake Reconstruction

Rural Housing Reconstruction and Sustainable Development Post Wenchuan Earthquake: A Land Unification Perspective Using Dujiangyan City as an Example

A comparison of two approaches to develop concentrated rural settlements after the 5.12 Sichuan Earthquake in China

Earthquake Disaster Challenging Chinese Rural Land Policy

Study on the Post-earthquake Sustainable Design and Construction for Rural House in Sichuan:Case Study on Steel Structural Experiment Unit of Rural House in Yinchi Village of Shifang

Models of rebuilding houses in quake-hit towns

The Thinking and Technology in Homeland Rebuilding of Mountain Village after Earthquake——Case study on the Homeland Rebuilding of Yamakoshi Village after Niigata Chuetsu Earthquake,2004

Survey of Self-built Transitional Shelter in Rural Areas after Wenchuan Earthquake

The Dilemma of Land Expansion and Governance in Rural China: A Comparative Study Based on Three Townships in Zhejiang Province

On Distribution Change Mode Of Rural Resident Land In China

Aseismic Issues of Farmstead and Schoolhouse on the Architectural Design Inspiration

Farmland Reconsolidation Planning based on Detailed Zoning Approach

Landscape Architecture Renovation Design in Shu Road's Traditional Villages: A Case Study of Jiuxian Village Pavilion

Analysis of Farmers' Satisfaction Towards Concentrated Rural Settlement Development after the Wenchuan Earthquake

The Feasibility of Concentrated Rural Settlement in a Context of Post-Disaster Reconstruction: a Study of China.

Thinking about the Rural Planning and Constructing Strategy from the Rural Dwellings' Planning Practices

Primary Study on Features and Implementation Framework of Environmental Impact Assessment for Post-earthquake Reconstruction Plan

Explanation of Urban Design by Practice of Reconstruction for Wenchuan Shuimo Town