Applying longitudinal differential protection against simultaneous lightning outage for double-circuit transmission lines on same tower
Hao Zhou,Xu Deng,Zhiheng Shen,Dongju Wang,Ke Sun,Yang Shen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13336/j.1003-6520.hve.2014.01.004
2014-01-01
Abstract:To prevent tripping accidents on double-circuit transmission lines on the same tower (DCSTTL) caused by simultaneous lightning outage, we studied the effect of using longitudinal differential protection. Firstly, we summarized the tripping characteristics and the actualities of relay application for DCSTTL, and analyzed the effects of some key factors, including phase sequence configuration, ground resistance, tower height, span of line and insulation level of tower, on lightning protection of transmission lines. Then, we compared the operations of different relay protection equipment on DCSTTL under typical lightning faults, and analyzed the effectiveness of using longitudinal differential protection to prevent simultaneous lightning outage for DCSTTL in quantity after considering practical line parameters. Results show that there is a large gap between the two-phase level and the three-phase lightning withstand level for DCSTTL. With longitudinal differential protection, a DCSTTL will only have power failure on a single circuit under three-phase flashover, and only flashovers on four and more phases will cause double-circuit line power-off on the line. Therefore, compared with pilot distance relays and directional pilot relays, longitudinal differential protection performs better in preventing simultaneous lightning outage. We also proposed some other suggestions from the perspective of relay protection for protecting DCSTTL.