Does Collaborative Learning Need Teachers' Facilitation

Liang Miao,Zheng Lanqin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-5195.2012.05.003

2012-01-01

Abstract:Collaborative learning, whose effectiveness in improving learners' comprehensive ability coincides with the talent quality requirement, has become a hot issue in both academic research and education practice. However, in the practice of collaborative learning, disagreements exist on whether teachers' facilitation is necessary, and what kind of facilitation is needed. Consequently, these confusions lead to the blindness and casualness during implementation processes, resulting in more chaos in collaborative learning. There are two opposite views about this issue: one in favor of learners' independent exploration, the other argues that learners' cognitive structure determines the necessity of teachers' facilitation. Though empirical research results all endorse teachers' facilitation, no unanimous conclusion can be reached when the teachers' characteristics that affect collaborative learning and specific methods of facilitation are studied. Moreover, empirical studies from the factor perspective are non-verifiable and non-scientific as they neglect the complexity of factors. The complex system theory can, to some extent, improve the scientificity of the research paradigm as it avoids the weakness of simple attribution and reveals the effectiveness of the operation of a system with the attributes of the system itself.