Effects of grade Ⅱ medial collateral ligament injury on anterior-posterior stability of knee after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: surgery versus conservative treatment

LIU Ri,DONG Jiang-tao,WANG Xin,GAO Shi-jun,CHEN Bai-cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-134X.2013.06.009

2013-01-01

Abstract:Objective To observe the effects of grade Ⅱ medial collateral ligament(MCL) injury treated by surgery or conservative treatment on the axial stability after the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Methods 54 cases of the anterior cruciate ligament injury with acute grade Ⅱ medial collateral ligament injury were chosen for the study. All the patients had been injured for less than one week. The preoperative MRI examination showed discontinuity of the anterior cruciate ligament,and high signals for the femoral and tibial insertions of the medial collateral ligament. The preoperative examination revealed that 30° valgus stress test and the anterior drawer test were positive,while 0° valgus stress test was negative. All the patients were randomly divided into two groups. All the patients were evaluated by KT 1000 measurement for anterior tibial translocation,the range of motion( ROM) of the knee,and IKDC scores. The arthroscopic single-bundle allograft reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament was performed both in group A and group B,while the medial collateral ligament was open repaired in the group A,and a 6-week brace fixation was used as a conservative treatment for MCL injury in the group B. All the patients underwent clinical effects assessment by IKDC score,ROM measurement,KT1000 measurement one year after the surgery. Results One year after the surgery,the improvement of IKDC score and the KT1000 measurement was significant in all patients compared with the preoperative data( P < 0. 05). There was no significant difference between the group A and the group B in IKDC score( P < 0. 05). There was no significant difference( P > 0. 05,t = 0. 672) between the two groups in the preoperative and postoperative joint activities. The axial stability after the operation was remarkably improved in the group A comparing with the group B,which was statistically significant( P < 0. 05). Conclusion It is suggested that the repair of grade Ⅱ medial collateral ligament injury should be adopted along with the reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament.