Democracy and Chinese Political Discourses

Yali Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/009770049802400403

IF: 0.75

1998-01-01

Modern China

Abstract:The absence of mass approval on the model of democracy has marked the debate both inside and outside China on the countrys political future. The lack of linkage between theories of democracy and the mass of the Chinese people diminishes the relevance of the debate. In this perspective this study intends to provide that linkage between democratic theory and the people who compose an actual or potential democracy within China. It approaches the issue from an empirical point of view utilizing the Q methodology on 64 statements from within the Chinese political context. Overall 4 Chinese political discourses are identified: radical democracy established conservatism concerned traditionalism and alienated populism. The study shows that although the Chinese are not politically homogenous they agree unanimously on the desirability of democracy. It uncovers opinions that are both pro-liberal democracy and pro-status quo as well as reveals widespread discontent about what is best described as rampant “rent seeking” under the present regime coupled with a strong sense of crisis and cynicism. Sharing the same cultural background these discourses have Chinese characteristics such as a concern over unity and a favorable opinion of meritocracy. Finally it does not support any argument that the Chinese peasants are apolitical or politically ignorant. Rather they do have distinctive political views.