Abstract:A collaborative study conducted by three police forensic units, a DNA laboratory, and a forensic academic institute was undertaken in order to compare the performance of four different swabs in controlled and quasi-operational conditions. For this purpose, a reference swab (Prionics cardboard evidence collection kit) currently used within the police forensic units and 3 challenger swabs (COPAN 4N6FLOQSwabs™ (Genetics variety), Puritan FAB-MINI-AP and Sarstedt Forensic Swab) were used for collecting DNA traces from previously used items (referred as "touch DNA" in this article) including on 60 collars, 60 screwdrivers and 60 steering wheels obtained from volunteers. For each comparison, the surface considered was divided into two equal components; one was sampled with the reference swab and the other with one of the three challenger swabs. This lead to a total of 360 samples. Conclusions were consistent within the four operational partners. From a practical point of view, the COPAN 4N6FLOQSwabs™ (Genetics variety) was judged the most convenient to use. Furthermore, it allowed the recovery of significantly more DNA from collars (0.65 vs 0.13 ng/μL) and steering wheels (2.82 vs 1.77 ng/μL), and a similar amount of DNA from screwdrivers (0.032 vs 0.026 ng/μL) compared with the Prionics reference swab. The two other challenger swabs provided results that were not significantly different from the reference swab, except for the Puritan swab, whose performance was significantly lower for steering wheels (0.37 vs 0.58 ng/μL). As part of a conservation study, 50 μL of a blood dilution (1/4 with PBS) was deposited on a total of 105 COPAN (Genetics and Crime Scene varieties), Prionics and Sarstedt swabs. They were stored within a cupboard at room temperature. The integrity of the recovered DNA was evaluated with NGM SElect™ DNA profiles after different time-spans ranging from 1 day to 12 months by comparing the height difference of the peaks occurring at the shortest and longest loci, respectively. DNA seemed to remain stable, except when using the COPAN 4N6FLOQSwabs™ treated with an antimicrobial agent (Crime scene variety), which resulted in significant DNA degradation. Following these tests, the COPAN 4N6FLOQSwabs™ (Genetics variety), a model with a desiccant, was selected for further testing in fully operational conditions.

Examination on STR of Human Cast-off Cells on Vehicle

Increased recovery of touch DNA evidence using FTA paper compared to conventional collection methods

Comparison of Three DNA Extraction Methods for Genotyping of Difficulty Mixed Stains

Experimental study on primary transfer and secondary transfer of DNA

The application of alkaline lysis and pressure cycling technology in the differential extraction of DNA from sperm and epithelial cells recovered from cotton swabs

Touch DNA collection - Performance of four different swabs

An exploratory study of effectiveness with ethylene oxide treatment for removing DNA contamination

[STR profiling of genomic DNA from HE stained tissue sections].

The Individual Identification and Clinical Application of STR

Integrated DNA purification, PCR, sample cleanup, and capillary electrophoresis microchip for forensic human identification.

Separation of Sperm and Epithelial Cells Based on the Hydrodynamic Effect for Forensic Analysis.

[STR genotyping in unbuffered formalin fixed paraffin embedded tissue].

The method of collecting sloughed epithelial cells by negative pressure from clothings

Identification of Cross Contamination of Human Cell Lines by STR Profiling

[Establishment of miniSTR fluorescent detection system and its forensic application].

Forensic Validation and Application Evaluation of IDentifier DNA Typing Kit (Yan-Huang34)

Validation of the DNATyper™15 PCR Genotyping System for Forensic Application

An assessment of DNA extraction methods from blood-stained soil in forensic science

[Extraction of Sperm DNA from Mixed Stain by the Modified Differential Lysis Method Combined with Silicon Bead Method].

A fully integrated microchip system for automated forensic short tandem repeat analysis.

Optimisation of a DNA extraction protocol from fingerprints for the analysis of nuclear STR and mitochondrial DNA genetic profiles