Comparison of Autofluorescence Bronchoscope and White Light Bronchoscope in Airway Examination for Patients with Central Type Lung Cancer

LI Yun,LI Xiao,SUI Xi-zhao,BU Liang,ZHOU Zu-li,YANG Fan,LIU Yan-guo,ZHAO Hui,LI Jian-feng,LIU Jun,JIANG Guan-chao,WANG Jun

2011-01-01

Abstract:Objective To compare the sensitivity and accuracy of autofluorescence bronchoscope(AFB) and white light bronchoscope(WLB) in airway examination for patients with central type lung cancer. Methods From September 2009 to May 2010,46 patients including 36 males and 10 females with an average age of 62.1 years underwent both AFB and WLB procedures in People's Hospital of Peking University.Among them,35 were preliminary diagnostic cases and 11 were postoperative surveillance cases.Local anaesthesia of glottis and airway,and general anaesthesia with continuous intravenous drugs were given before electric bronchoscope was adopted.All patients underwent WLB examination followed by AFB procedure.All suspicious abnormal visual findings were recorded for biopsy and pathological examination. Results All procedures were carried out safely without death or severe complications.We performed bronchoscopy 48 times for all 46 patients and 159 tissues of various sites were taken out for biopsy and pathologic examination which showed 64 malignancies and 95 none malignancies.In 64 malignancies,AFB found all but WLB missed 15 with a missed diagnosis rate of 23.4%.Thirty-six times of examination were performed for the 35 preliminary diagnostic cases and 56 sites of malignancy were found.AFB found all,while WLB missed 12,and 6 sites of malignancy found by AFB were larger in size than those found by WLB.AFB detected 3 cases of multi-site malignancy,but WLB missed these diagnoses.The results of AFB and WLB were the same for 26 patients.Twelve times of bronchoscopy were performed for the 11 postoperative surveillance cases and 8 sites of malignancy were found.AFB found them all while WLB missed 3 which were two recurrent cases during the early period after lung cancer surgery.The sensitivity of AFB and WLB was 100.0 % and 76.6%(P<0.05) respectively,and the negative predictive value of AFB and WLB was 100.0% and 84.5%(P=0.002) respectively. Conclusion AFB has a better sensitivity and negative predictive value than WLB in detecting mucous canceration lesions in central type lung cancer,and is more accurate in assessment of tumor margins,more sensitive in finding multiple lesions in airway and detecting early cancer recurrence in postoperative surveillance patients.