Triply switchable bioelectrocatalysis based on poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) hydrogel films with immobilized glucose oxidase

Yan Liang,Shaoling Song,Huiqin Yao,Naifei Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electacta.2011.03.052

IF: 6.6

2011-01-01

Electrochimica Acta

Abstract:Poly( N -isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM) hydrogel films containing glucose oxidase (GOD), designated as PNIPAM-GOD, were synthesized on the surface of pyrolytic graphite (PG) electrodes through radical cross-linking polymerization method. Cyclic voltammetric (CV) response of ferrocenecarboxylic acid (Fc(COOH)) at PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes was very sensitive to the environmental temperature, sulfate concentration, and addition of methanol solvent. For example, at 25 °C, Fc(COOH) exhibited a quasi-reversible CV peak pair with large peak currents in pH 7.0 aqueous solutions containing no sulfate for the films; while at 37 °C, the CV response was greatly suppressed. By switching the film electrodes in solutions between 25 and 37 °C, the CV peak currents of Fc(COOH) cycled between a quite large value and a very small one, showing the reversible thermo-sensitive switching property between the on and off states. Similarly, the reversible SO 4 2− - and methanol-sensitive on–off behavior of the films toward the probe was also observed. This triply responsive property could be used to realize the thermo-, SO 4 2− -, and methanol-controlled electrochemical oxidation of glucose catalyzed by GOD immobilized in the films and mediated by Fc(COOH) in solution. This “smart” interface may establish a foundation for fabricating a novel type of multi-controllable biosensors based on bioelectrocatalysis. Keywords Glucose oxidase Poly( N -isopropylacrylamide) Bioelectrocatalysis Switchable property Ferrocenecarboxylic acid 1 Introduction Electrochemical biosensors based on enzymes nowadays have become a type of very commonly used ones and attracted increasing attention among researchers due to the high specificity and intrinsic sensitivity of enzymatic reactions [1–4] . In recent years, switchable bioelectrocatalysis with enzymes induced by external stimuli has aroused more and more interest because it can not only be applied to fabricate switchable bioelectronic devices such as biosensors, bioreactors, and biofuel cells, but may also provide a basis for information storage, signal amplification and transformation [5–7] . Therefore, the development of switchable bioelectrocatalysis is of great importance in both fundamental and application studies. Various external stimuli, such as pH [8–11] , light [12,13] , magnetic fields [5,14,15] , and electric fields [16] have been used to modulate or control bioelectrocatalysis. For example, Willner and co-workers reported that by varying position of magnets below and above the electrochemical cell, the ferrocene-modified magnetic particles were attracted to and repulsed from the electrode surface, leading to the on and off states toward the electrocatalytic oxidation of glucose by glucose oxidase (GOD), respectively [15] . In our recent work, oppositely charged poly(allylamine hydrochloride) (PAH) and hyaluronic acid (HA) were assembled into {PAH/HA} n layer-by-layer (LBL) films on pyrolytic graphite (PG) electrodes with GOD loaded into the films. The films showed a reversible pH-sensitive cyclic voltammetric (CV) on–off behavior toward ferrocenedicarboxylic acid (Fc(COOH) 2 ), and could be used to switch the electrocatalytic oxidation of glucose by GOD immobilized in the films and mediated by Fc(COOH) 2 in solution [11] . Among the stimuli-responsive bioelectrocatalysis, multi-responsive one is of particularly interest since the response to several stimuli is one of the major properties in life processes. For instance, different external signals may simultaneously induce the same alteration in the living processes, such as the change of protein conformation, gating of ions across a cell membrane, changes in the permeability and mechanical properties of human skin, and the on–off of biocatalytic reactions involving enzymes. While the multiple signal-triggered systems, including polymer hydrogel films, have been reported previously [17–19] , to the best of our knowledge, the report on multi-switchable bioelectrocatalysis based on enzymatic reactions has been very limited until now [20,21] . The development of multi-responsive bioelectrocatalysis is still a great challenge. For example, in our previous study [20] , poly( N -isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM) films were electrochemically polymerized on gold electrodes and showed reversible CV on–off behavior toward ferrocenecarboxylic acid (Fc(COOH)) dependent on both surrounding temperature and sulfate concentration. Dually and synergistically switchable electrocatalytic oxidation of glucose by GOD and mediated by Fc(COOH) was realized. However, the major disadvantage of the above system [20] is that the enzyme GOD was in the solution phase and was not immobilized in the PNIPAM films. As well-known, the immobilization of enzymes on electrode surface is a necessary and important step in constructing electrochemical biosensors, and can significantly enhance the stability and application efficiency of enzymes [22,23] . Considering that the electropolymerization with relatively high potentials was not suitable to immobilize GOD in the PNIPAM films, in the present work, the radical cross-linking polymerization was used to synthesize PNIPAM hydrogel films on PG electrodes and GOD was directly entrapped in the films during the polymerization procedure. In PNIPAM hydrogel films, the enzyme such as laccase immobilized with the similar method was reported to retain its original structure and bioactivity [24] . We thus expected that GOD entrapped in PNIPAM hydrogel films synthesized by chemical polymerization could also keep its native structure and biological activity. PNIPAM is a typical and widely investigated thermo-sensitive polymer that undergoes a phase transition at the lower critical solution temperature (LCST) of about 32 °C in aqueous solution [25,26] . When the external temperature is below the LCST, the hydrogel is swollen and takes an expanded coil conformation, mainly due to the formation of hydrogen bonds between its amide groups and water molecules, making the gel become hydrophilic. When the surrounding temperature is above the LCST, the gel is shrunken and dehydrated to the collapsed globule state, because the hydrogen bonds between PNIPAM and water are broken, making the gel network become aggregate and hydrophobic after the water molecules are expelled from the gel. In addition, salt identity and concentration in solution may significantly influence the LCST of PNIPAM, and the different effect of cations and anions may follow the Hofmeister series [27–29] . Usually, the increase of salt concentration leads to the decrease of the LCST of PNIPAM [27,29] . Thus, the change of salt concentration can also induce the phase transition between the expanded coil state and the collapsed globule state, based on the same mechanism of thermo-responsive behavior of PNIPAM [27,29–31] . Recently, Willner and co-workers reported that various metal ions could be incorporated into PNIPAM films, and the metal ion-functionalized PNIPAM matrices showed ion-dependent phase transition temperatures [32] . Moreover, the addition of water-miscible organic solvent such as methanol may also induce the phase transition of PNIPAM [33–35] . With the increase of methanol in water/methanol mixture solvents, the PNIPAM exhibits the swelling-to-shrinking-to-swelling or coil-to-globule-to-coil transition. The thermo- and/or salt-dependent structure change of PNIPAM films acted as the stimuli-responsive switch has been reported in the previous literature [20,36,37] . However, the methanol-responsive PNIPAM switch, especially combined with its thermo- and salt-sensitive on–off property, has not been reported up to now. This prompted us to use the triple stimuli, including external temperature, salt concentration, and addition of methanol, to trigger the structure change of PNIPAM hydrogel films in this study. In the present work, PNIPAM hydrogel films were synthesized on the PG electrodes by radical cross-linking polymerization and used to immobilize GOD at the same time. The electroactive probe Fc(COOH) demonstrated CV on–off behavior at the as-prepared PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes depending on temperature, sulfate concentration, and the amount of methanol in water/methanol mixture solvents. This triply triggered switching property could be further used to control the electrochemical oxidation of glucose catalyzed by GOD immobilized in the films with Fc(COOH) as the mediator in solution. The present report provided a novel model to realize triply switchable bioelectrocatalysis with enzymes immobilized on the electrode surface. This may open up the possibility of applying this type of “smart” or intelligent interface in electrochemical biosensors or other biodevices based on multi-responsive bioelectrocatalysis. 2 Experimental 2.1 Reagents N -isopropylacrylamide (NIPAM) was obtained from TCI Chemicals. Ferrocenecarboxylic acid (Fc(COOH)), glucose oxidase (GOD, E.C. 1.1.3.4, type VII, 192,000 units g −1 ), N , N ′-methylenebisacrylamide (BIS), and N , N , N ′, N ′-tetramethylethylenediamine (TEMED) were purchased from Sigma–Aldrich. Glucose was obtained from Beijing Yili Fine Chemicals. Sodium sulfate (Na 2 SO 4 ) was purchased from Tianjin Tanggu Dengzhong Chemical Plant. Sodium persulfate (Na 2 S 2 O 8 ) was purchased from Aladdin Reagents. Methanol was obtained from Beijing Chemical Plant. Other chemicals were of analytical grade. Britton–Robinson buffers containing 0.1 M NaCl at pH 7.0 were usually used. Solutions were prepared with water purified twice by ion exchange and subsequent distillation. 2.2 Preparation of PNIPAM-GOD hydrogel films on electrodes PNIPAM hydrogel films containing GOD, designated as PNIPAM-GOD, were prepared on basal plane pyrolytic graphite (PG, Advanced Ceramics, geometric area 0.16 cm 2 ) disk electrodes according to the procedure reported previously [24,38] with some modification. Prior to coating, the PG electrode was abraded with metallographic sandpaper of 320 grits while flushed with water. The electrode was then ultrasonicated in water for 30 s and dried in air. After the electrode was placed in a sealed bottle under a high-purity N 2 atmosphere for about 5 min, 5 μL of the pre-gel solution was cast on the electrode surface with a microsyringe. Herein, the typical pre-gel solution containing 2.0 mg mL −1 GOD, 0.4 M NIPAM, 2.0 mg mL −1 BIS (as a cross-linker), 0.7 mg mL −1 TEMED (as an accelerator), and 0.7 mg mL −1 Na 2 S 2 O 8 (as an initiator) was freshly prepared every time and deaerated with N 2 before being cast. The PNIPAM-GOD films were then formed on PG surface in about 10 min. During the whole polymerization procedure, the N 2 atmosphere was kept in the sealed bottle. After the polymerization, the PNIPAM-GOD hydrogel modified electrode was immersed in water for about 30 min to remove the remaining monomer and other unreacted chemicals. 2.3 Apparatus and procedures A CHI 660A electrochemical workstation (CH Instruments) was used for all electrochemical measurements. A traditional three-electrode cell system was used with a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) as the reference, a platinum wire as the counter, and the PG electrode with films as the working electrode. Before electrochemical measurements, the buffer in the cell was purged with high-purity nitrogen for at least 15 min, and a N 2 atmosphere was then maintained over the cell during the whole experiments. The temperature of solutions in the cell was controlled by an HH-S thermostatic bath (Zhengzhou Greatwall Scientific Industrial and Trade Co.) with a precision of ±0.2 °C. The IR spectra were recorded on a Varian 3100 FT-IR spectrophotometer (Varian) at a resolution of 4 cm −1 . Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was run with an X-650 scanning electron microanalyzer (Hitachi) at an acceleration voltage of 5.0 kV. SEM sample films were prepared on PG disks in the same way as for electrochemistry. After treated with different temperatures, Na 2 SO 4 concentrations, and amounts of methanol, the PNIPAM-GOD sample films were transferred into liquid nitrogen immediately to “freeze” their structure, followed by the freeze-drying in a FD-3 freeze drier (Beijing Boyikang Experimental Instrument) for 24 h until all water in the films was sublimed. Prior to SEM analysis, very thin Pt films were coated on the surface of films with an E-1045 sputtering coater (Hitachi). 3 Results and discussion 3.1 Preparation of PNIPAM-GOD hydrogel films on PG electrodes PNIPAM hydrogel films containing GOD on PG electrodes were polymerized by radical cross-linking method mainly according to the procedure reported by the literature [24,38] with some modification. The formation of PNIPAM in PNIPAM-GOD films was confirmed by IR spectroscopy in comparison with the pure PNIPAM sample obtained commercially ( Supplementary materials Fig. S1 ). All characteristic peaks of PNIPAM, such as amide I band at 1653 cm −1 and amide II band at 1541 cm −1 , were observed at the same or similar positions for PNIPAM-GOD films, and consistent with those reported by the literature [39,40] . The GOD in PNIPAM-GOD could not be detected by IR spectroscopy since the typical absorption peaks of GOD such as amide I and II bands were overlapped by PNIPAM, and the amount of GOD in the PNIPAM-GOD films was relatively small. The formation of PNIPAM-GOD films on PG electrodes was further confirmed by CV with Fc(COOH) as the electroactive probe. At bare PG electrodes, Fc(COOH) showed a pair of quasi-reversible CV peaks at about 0.26 V, characteristic of Fc/Fc + redox couple ( Supplementary materials Fig. S2 , curve a). At PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes, while Fc(COOH) also demonstrated a well-defined and nearly reversible CV redox peak pair at the same position, the peak heights at the steady state became obviously smaller ( Fig. S2 , curve b). This is because the PNIPAM-GOD films act as a diffusion barrier that restrains some of the probes from reaching the electrode surface, leading to the decrease of the peak currents. The CV response of Fc(COOH) was also dependent on the thickness of PNIPAM-GOD films or the amount of NIPAM monomer in polymerization. The oxidation peak current ( I pa ) of Fc(COOH) at the steady state decreased with the increase of the amount of NIPAM in polymerization ( Fig. 1 , curve b), indicating that the thicker PNIPAM-GOD films would cause the diffusion of the probe to become more difficult in the films and then result in the smaller CV peak heights. The CV response time of the probe was also dependent on the film thickness. Herein, the response time is defined as the duration from the immersion of the films into the Fc(COOH) solution to the reaching of CV steady state of the probe. For example, for PNIPAM-GOD films with 2 μmol NIPAM monomer in polymerization, the CV response of Fc(COOH) gradually increased with the cycle number ( n ) of continuous CV scans until n = 7 at 0.05 V s −1 between 0 and 0.6 V, and then reached the steady state ( Supplementary materials Fig. S3 ). Thus, the CV response time in this case was less than 3 min. The response time of Fc(COOH) at the steady state decreased with the decrease of the amount of NIPAM in polymerization ( Fig. 1 , curve a), suggesting that the thinner PNIPAM-GOD films would lead to the faster CV response of the probe. Considering that the rapid response is preferred for the switchable stimuli-responsive films, the PNIPAM-GOD films with 2 μmol of NIPAM monomer in polymerization were used in the following experiments. 3.2 Thermo-responsive behavior of PNIPAM-GOD films The CV behavior of Fc(COOH) in pH 7.0 buffers at PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes was very sensitive to the temperature of the testing solution. When the temperature was below 31 °C, the CV responses were quite large and kept at nearly the same level; when the temperature was above 31 °C, however, the peak currents dramatically decreased with temperature ( Fig. 2 A) , showing a phase transition temperature at about 31 °C in the curve of CV I pa versus temperature ( Fig. 2 B, curve a). This phase transition temperature is very close to the LCST for PNIPAM hydrogel at around 32 °C [25,26] , suggesting that the entrapped GOD in the PNIPAM films has little influence on the LCST of the hydrogel. The thermo-sensitive CV response of Fc(COOH) at PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes could be used to study the on–off switching property of the films. In this work, two typical temperatures, 25 and 37 °C, were selected according to Fig. 2 A. At 25 °C, Fc(COOH) exhibited a pair of well-defined and nearly reversible CV peaks with quite large peak currents for the films ( Fig. 2 A, curve a), indicating that the films were at the on state; at 37 °C, however, the CV response of the probe was greatly suppressed ( Fig. 2 A, curve f), and the films were at the off state. This temperature-responsive on–off behavior of the films toward Fc(COOH) was reversible ( Fig. 3 ). By switching the film electrode in buffers containing Fc(COOH) between 25 and 37 °C, the corresponding CV I pa could cycle between the on and off states for many times, although the response time for the two different directions was slightly different. The response time from 25 to 37 °C was less than 3 min, while that from 37 to 25 °C was about 6 min ( Fig. 3 ). The temperature-sensitive on–off property of PNIPAM-GOD films toward Fc(COOH) can be explained by the thermo-responsive structure change of PNIPAM films in aqueous solutions. Below LCST, such as 25 °C, the hydrogen bonding between hydrophilic amide groups of PNIPAM and water molecules in solution is predominant, the films can thus load a large amount of water and take the swollen and expanded coil structure in solution [41,42] . This would enhance the film permeability and make the small-molecular electroactive probe diffuse through the films very easily, resulting in the quite large CV response. When the temperature is increased to above LCST, such as 37 °C, the hydrogen bonds between PNIPAM and water molecules are broken, and the attractive inter- and intra-molecular hydrophobic interactions within PNIPAM become overwhelming. At these temperatures, most of the water originally entrapped in the films are squeezed out, the PNIPAM films would take the shrunken and compact globule structure in solution [41,42] , which would restrict the probe to transport through the films, leading to the very small CV signal. The structure change of PNIPAM-GOD films treated with different temperatures was further confirmed by SEM. The PNIPAM-GOD films on PG disks were first incubated in pH 7.0 buffers at a specific temperature for about 5 min, and then transferred into the liquid nitrogen immediately to “freeze” the structure, followed by the freeze-drying before SEM measurements. The surface morphology of PNIPAM-GOD films incubated at 25 and 37 °C was obviously different ( Fig. 4 A and B) . At 25 °C, the films demonstrated a lot of larger-sized pores and channels on the surface, while at 37 °C, the films displayed a much more compact structure. 3.3 Na 2 SO 4 -sensitive property of PNIPAM-GOD films The CV response of Fc(COOH) at PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes was also sensitive to the identity and concentration of salts in buffer solutions. Taking Na 2 SO 4 as an example, when the concentration of Na 2 SO 4 in solution was below 0.15 M at 25 °C, a quasi-reversible CV peak pair with large peak heights of the probe for the films was observed; when Na 2 SO 4 concentration was above 0.15 M, however, the CV peak currents decreased dramatically with the Na 2 SO 4 concentration ( Supplementary materials Fig. S4 ). From the sigmoid shaped curve of CV I pa versus Na 2 SO 4 concentration ( Fig. 5 , curve a), the critical phase transition concentration was clearly observed at about 0.15 M at 25 °C, very close to that reported in the literature [29,43] . The Na 2 SO 4 -sensitive CV property of Fc(COOH) for PNIPAM-GOD films could also be used to study the on–off switching behavior of the films. Two typical Na 2 SO 4 concentrations, 0 and 0.30 M, were selected in the present work. The films were at the on state with no Na 2 SO 4 in solution, at which the probe showed a quite large CV response ( Fig. S4 , curve a); with the concentration of Na 2 SO 4 at 0.30 M in solution, however, the films were at the off state, and the CV signal of the probe became very small ( Fig. S4 , curve f). This Na 2 SO 4 -dependent on–off behavior of the films toward Fc(COOH) was also reversible, and the switching cycle between the on and off states could be repeated for many times ( Supplementary materials Fig. S5 ). The response time of the films toward Fc(COOH) was less than 3 min when the concentration of Na 2 SO 4 in solution was changed from 0 to 0.30 M, while the response time became about 8 min when the Na 2 SO 4 concentration was changed back from 0.30 to 0 M ( Fig. S5 ). The essence of phase transition of PNIPAM-GOD films induced by Na 2 SO 4 concentration is the same as that induced by temperature [27,29–31] . Below the critical concentration of Na 2 SO 4 , the PNIPAM would take expanded coil conformation because of the predominating hydrogen bonding between hydrophilic amide groups of PNIPAM and water molecules in solution. Fc(COOH) would thus diffuse through the films easily, leading to the large CV response. When the concentration of Na 2 SO 4 is above the critical one, the hydrogen bonding between PNIPAM and water molecules would be greatly impeded, leading to the formation of contracted globule structure [27,43] . It would therefore become difficult for the probe to go through the compact films, resulting in the very small CV signal. The structure change of PNIPAM-GOD films with Na 2 SO 4 concentration was also confirmed by SEM ( Fig. 4 A and C). The films treated with 0.30 M Na 2 SO 4 in buffers were much more compact and less porous than those without Na 2 SO 4 . It is noteworthy that the effect of Na 2 SO 4 concentration and temperature on the structure change of PNIPAM films and the corresponding CV on–off behavior of Fc(COOH) is not independent but synergetic [20] . For example, the LCST of PNIPAM films was shifted from 31 to 20 °C when the Na 2 SO 4 concentration in solution increased from 0 to 0.30 M ( Fig. 2 B), and the critical phase transition concentration of Na 2 SO 4 was changed from 0.15 to 0.50 M when the temperature was lowered from 25 to 15 °C ( Fig. 5 ). In fact, other salts could also induce the on–off behavior of PNIPAM-GOD films toward Fc(COOH). For example, NaCl and NaBr showed the critical phase transition concentration at 0.40 and 0.75 M in the CV I pa versus concentration curves at 25 °C, respectively ( Fig. 6 , curves b and c). The three salts, Na 2 SO 4 , NaCl, and NaBr, have the same cation Na + but different anions. The different critical concentrations for them suggest that the anion influences the phase transition of PNIPAM-GOD films more significantly than the cation in solution, being consistent with the observation in the literature [27,29] . The critical concentration of the anions exhibited the sequence of Br − (0.75 M) > Cl − (0.40 M) > SO 4 2− (0.15 M), in good agreement with the Hofmeister series [44–46] . SO 4 2− is believed to be a kosmotropic or “water structure making” anion, while Br − is a kind of chaotropic or “water structure breaking” anion [47,48] . Considering that SO 4 2− is more sensitive than the other two anions in inducing the phase transition of the films and the enzyme GOD in the PNIPAM-GOD films may alter its conformation and lose its bioactivity in the presence of high concentration of salts in solution, in the present work, SO 4 2− was selected as the model anion to stimulate the structure change of PNIPAM-GOD films and the corresponding CV response change of Fc(COOH) at the film electrodes. 3.4 Methanol-sensitive property of PNIPAM-GOD films The CV behavior of Fc(COOH) at PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes was also sensitive to the volume fraction of methanol in water/methanol mixture solvent ( Supplementary materials Fig. S6 ). When the fraction of methanol was below 16%, the CV response of the probe was quite large and kept at nearly the same level, showing no substantial difference compared with that with no addition of methanol. The peak currents then dramatically decreased with the fraction of methanol and reached the very small values when the methanol fraction was between 20 and 35%. When the fraction of methanol was further increased, the responsive signals of the probe increased with the methanol fraction again ( Fig. 7 ). The methanol-sensitive CV property of Fc(COOH) at PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes could also be used to study the on–off behavior of the system. Herein, two typical methanol volume fraction, 0 and 20%, were selected. The films were at the on state with no methanol in solution, at which the probe showed a quite large CV response ( Fig. S6 , curve a); with the fraction of methanol at 20% in solution, however, the films were at the off state, and the CV signal of the probe became very small ( Fig. S6 , curve d). This methanol-dependent on–off behavior of the system was reversible, and the switching cycle between the on and off states could be repeated for many times ( Supplementary materials Fig. S7 ). The response time of the system was between 3 and 6 min depending on the changing direction. In control experiments, bare PG electrodes were used to examine the influence of the fraction of methanol on CV response of Fc(COOH) ( Supplementary materials Fig. S8 ). With 20% methanol in solution, the CV peaks of the probe showed only a slight decrease compared with those with no methanol, suggesting that the methanol-sensitive property of the probe for PNIPAM-GOD films has little relationship with the character of Fc(COOH) itself in two different solvents and should be attributed to the films. The essence of phase transition of PNIPAM-GOD films induced by methanol fraction in the water/methanol mixture solvent is the same as that induced by temperature or Na 2 SO 4 concentration [33,34] . The addition of methanol into water in the fraction range of 10–20% may induce the break of the hydrogen bonds between PNIPAM and water molecules and cause the transition of the films from the swollen hydrated state to the collapsed dehydrated state, thus leading to the drastic decrease of CV response of Fc(COOH). The structure change of PNIPAM-GOD films caused by methanol was also observed by SEM after the films were treated by 20% methanol ( Fig. 4 A and D). However, it is interesting to note that the CV peaks of the probe increased with the further addition of methanol when the methanol fraction was larger than about 35% ( Fig. 7 ). This could be explained by the formation of hydrogen bonds between PNIPAM and methanol molecules [34] . These newly formed hydrogen bonds make the films expand and swell again, allowing the probe to diffuse through the films more easily and leading to the larger CV signals. This coil-to-globule-to-coil phase transition with the increase of methanol fraction in water/methanol mixture solvents for PNIPAM was also observed in the literature [33,34] . 3.5 Bioactivity of GOD in PNIPAM-GOD films One of our major concerns for the PNIPAM-GOD films in this work was whether the GOD enzyme immobilized in the films could retain its native structure and bioactivity. Since the IR spectroscopic results could not provide convincing evidence that the GOD in the films keeps its original conformation ( Fig. S1 ), the biocatalytic activity of GOD in the films toward glucose was tested by CV with Fc(COOH) as the electron transfer mediator. When glucose was added into the Fc(COOH) solution at pH 7.0 containing no Na 2 SO 4 and methanol at 25 °C, the CV oxidation peak of Fc(COOH) at PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes increased dramatically in comparison with that in the absence of glucose, accompanied by the decrease or even disappearance of the reduction peak ( Fig. 8 ). The oxidation peak current ( I pa ) increased initially with the concentration of glucose and then tended to level off ( Supplementary materials Fig. S9 ). All these are characteristic of electrochemical oxidation of glucose catalyzed by GOD and mediated by Fc(COOH), and the mechanism can be expressed by the following equations [49] : GOD(FAD) + glucose → GOD(FADH 2 ) + gluconic acid GOD(FADH 2 ) + 2Fc(COOH) Ox → GOD(FAD) + 2Fc(COOH) Red Fc(COOH) Red − e − ⇌ Fc(COOH) Ox , at electrode where GOD(FAD) and GOD(FADH 2 ) represent oxidized and reduced forms of glucose oxidase, respectively. The typical electrocatalytic behavior of the system is evidence that the GOD entrapped in the PNIPAM films retains its bioactivity and the PNIPAM-GOD films can be used to electrocatalyze the oxidation of glucose with the help of the mediator. 3.6 Switchable bioelectrocatalysis controlled by temperature, SO 4 2− concentration, and addition of methanol The thermo-, SO 4 2− -, and methanol-sensitive switching property of PNIPAM-GOD films toward Fc(COOH) could be used to control or modulate the electrochemical oxidation of glucose catalyzed by GOD in the films. For example, when the PNIPAM-GOD film electrode was placed in the solution containing Fc(COOH) and glucose without SO 4 2− and methanol at 25 °C, the CV catalytic oxidation wave was quite large ( Fig. 9 , curve a). However, when the same PNIPAM-GOD film was placed in the same solution at 37 °C, the electrocatalytic response became very small ( Fig. 9 , curve b). This is because the film became “closed” to Fc(COOH) at 37 °C, resulting in the interruption of the catalytic cycle. Therefore, the bioelectrocatalytic oxidation of glucose could be switched between the on and off states by switching the solution temperature between 25 and 37 °C. This thermo-responsive switching bioelectrocatalysis was reversible, and the on–off behavior for the system could be repeated for several cycles ( Supplementary materials Fig. S10A ). In addition, the CV oxidation peak current ratio, I pa25 / I pa37 , could be amplified by the bioelectrocatalysis, where I pa25 and I pa37 represented CV oxidation peak current at 25 and 37 °C for the same PNIPAM-GOD films, respectively. In the pH 7.0 aqueous buffer containing only 0.5 mM Fc(COOH) but without glucose, the I pa25 / I pa37 ratio was about 4.5, while in the solution containing both Fc(COOH) and glucose, the ratio increased to about 10.5. The bioelectrocatalysis of glucose for the system could also be modulated by SO 4 2− concentration. At 25 °C, in aqueous solutions containing Fc(COOH) and glucose in the absence of SO 4 2− , the films demonstrated a large catalytic wave ( Fig. 9 , curve a). In the presence of 0.30 M Na 2 SO 4 , however, the CV response was greatly suppressed ( Fig. 9 , curve c). This SO 4 2− -concentration-dependent on–off bioelectrocatalysis for the PNIPAM-GOD films was also reversible. By switching the same films in the Fc(COOH) + glucose solution at 25 °C containing SO 4 2− between 0 and 0.30 M, the CV I pa cycled between a relatively large value and a very small one for at least several times ( Fig. S10B ). Similar on–off bioelectrocatalysis for the system was also observed before and after methanol was added into the aqueous solution to the fraction of 20% ( Fig. 9 , curves a and d). The reversible on–off cycle could be repeated many times ( Fig. S10C ), suggesting that 20% methanol in the water/methanol mixture solvent cannot destroy the bioactivity of GOD in the films. 4 Conclusions PNIPAM hydrogel films containing GOD are successfully synthesized on the PG electrodes by radical cross-linking polymerization method. The PNIPAM-GOD films demonstrate reversible thermo-, sulfate-, and methanol-responsive CV on–off behavior toward Fc(COOH) mainly because of the corresponding phase transition or structure change of PNIPAM in the films between the expanded coil state and the contracted globule state. This multi-triggered CV behavior of the probe at the PNIPAM-GOD film electrodes can be used to control and switch the electrochemical oxidation of glucose catalyzed by GOD immobilized in the films and mediated by Fc(COOH) in solution. Compared with our previous work [20] , the main novelty of the present work is the immobilization of GOD in the films. Since the high potentials used in electropolymerization may denature or even destroy GOD, the electrochemical polymerization method in [20] is not suitable to immobilize the enzyme into PNIPAM films. Thus, the chemical polymerization is used in the present study to synthesize the PNIPAM films. With this method, GOD can be directly and easily entrapped in the PNIPAM films and retain its native structure and catalytic activity. Since the PNIPAM-GOD films synthesized by chemical polymerization is thicker than the PNIPAM films synthesized by electrochemical polymerization, the CV response time of Fc(COOH) for the former is longer than that for the latter. Nevertheless, the CV response time is only 3–8 min for the PNIPAM-GOD films during the switching. Moreover, the present work realizes for the first time the triply switchable bioelectrocatalysis, especially the methanol-sensitive one. This system provides a new way to achieve multi-switchable bioelectrocatalysis with the enzyme immobilized on the surface of electrodes, which may establish a foundation for fabricating multi-controllable biosensors based on enzymatic reactions with immobilized enzymes. Acknowledgments The financial support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NAFC 20975015 and 20775009 ) is acknowledged. We also thank Mr. Jing Zhao and Professor Huiliang Wang of Beijing Normal University for their help in synthesis of PNIPAM. Appendix A Supplementary data Supplementary data associated with this article can be found, in the online version, at doi:10.1016/j.electacta.2011.03.052 . Appendix A Supplementary data References [1] F.W. Scheller U. Wollenberger A. Warsinke F. Lisdat Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. 12 2001 35 [2] A. Chaubey B.D. Malhotra Biosens. Bioelectron. 17 2002 441 [3] L. Murphy Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. 10 2006 177 [4] G.S. Wilson Y. Hu Chem. Rev. 100 2000 2693 [5] I. Willner E. Katz Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 42 2003 4576 [6] I. Willner E. Katz Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 39 2000 1180 [7] M. Pita E. Katz Electroanalysis 21 2009 252 [8] T.K. Tam M. Ornatska M. Pita S. Minko E. Katz J. Phys. Chem. C 112 2008 8438 [9] H. Yao N. Hu J. Phys. Chem. B 113 2009 16021 [10] H. Yao N. Hu J. Phys. Chem. B 114 2010 3380 [11] D. Liu H. Liu N. Hu Electrochim. Acta 55 2010 6426 [12] I. Willner Acc. Chem. Res. 30 1997 347 [13] R. Blonder E. Katz I. Willner V. Wray A.F. Buckmann J. Am. Chem. Soc. 119 1997 11747 [14] M. Riskin B. Basnar Y. Huang I. Willner Adv. Mater. 19 2007 2691 [15] R. Hirsch E. Katz I. Willner J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122 2000 12053 [16] E. Katz I. Willner J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125 2003 6803 [17] I. Tokarev S. Minko Adv. Mater. 21 2009 241 [18] J. Zhang L. Chu Y. Li Y.M. Lee Polymer 48 2007 1718 [19] M. Karbarz K. Pulka A. Misicka Z. Stojek Langmuir 22 2006 7843 [20] S. Song N. Hu J. Phys. Chem. B 114 2010 5940 [21] S. Song N. Hu J. Phys. Chem. B 114 2010 11689 [22] M.F. Chaplin C. Bucke Enzyme Technology 1990 Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK [23] A.P.F. Turner I. Karube G.S. Wilson Biosensors: Fundamentals and Applications 1987 Oxford University Press New York [24] M. Klis M. Karbarz Z. Stojek J. Rogalski R. Bilewicz J. Phys. Chem. B 113 2009 6062 [25] H.G. Schild Prog. Polym. Sci. 17 1992 163 [26] Y. Katsumoto T. Tanaka H. Sato Y. Ozaki J. Phys. Chem. A 106 2002 3429 [27] M. Annaka K. Motokawa S. Sasaki T. Nakahira H. Kawasaki H. Maeda Y. Amo Y. Tominaga J. Chem. Phys. 113 2000 5980 [28] M.J.N. Junk I. Anac B. Menges U. Jonas Langmuir 26 2010 12253 [29] R. Freitag F. Garret-Flaudy Langmuir 18 2002 3434 [30] E. Krasovitski Y. Cohen H. Bianco-Peled J. Polym. Sci. B: Polym. Phys. 42 2004 3713 [31] C.M. Burba S.M. Carter K.J. Meyer C.V. Rice J. Phys. Chem. B 112 2008 10399 [32] M. Riskin R. Tel-Vered I. Willner Adv. Funct. Mater. 19 2009 2474 [33] G. Liu G. Zhang Langmuir 21 2005 2086 [34] G. Zhang C. Wu J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123 2001 1376 [35] M. Asano F.M. Winnik T. Yamashita K. Horie Langmuir 28 1995 5861 [36] Z. Zhu S.A. Sukhishvili ACS Nano 3 2009 3595 [37] J. Zhou G. Wang J. Hu X. Lu J. Li Chem. Commun. 46 2006 4820 [38] M. Karbarz M. Gniadek Z. Stojek Electroanalysis 21 2009 1363 [39] J. Reuber H. Reinhardt D. Johannsmann Langmuir 22 2006 3362 [40] Y.V. Pan R.A. Wesley R. Luginbuhl D.D. Denton B.D. Ratner Biomacromolecules 2 2001 32 [41] Y.J. Hoi T. Yamaguchi S. Nakao Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 39 2000 2491 [42] X. Wang X. Qiu C. Wu Macromolecules 31 1998 2972 [43] Y. Zhang S. Furyk D.E. Bergbreiter P.S. Cremer J. Am. Chem. Soc. 127 2005 14505 [44] M.C. Gurau S.M. Lim E.T. Castellana F. Albertorio S. Kataoka P.S. Cremer J. Am. Chem. Soc. 126 2004 10522 [45] W. Kunz J. Henle B.W. Ninham Curr. Opin. Colloid Interface Sci. 9 2004 19 [46] F. Hofmeister Arch. Exp. Pathol. Pharmakol. 24 1888 247 [47] Y. Zhang P.S. Cremer Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. 10 2006 658 [48] H. Zhao J. Mol. Catal. B: Enzym. 37 2005 16 [49] J. Wang Chem. Rev. 108 2008 814