Abstract:How to deal with China? This is the biggest question confronting U.S. trade policy—or even the United States’ entire foreign policy—today. Over the past few years, the debate on this important issue has benefited from the contributions of many trade law scholars, including those by Mark Wu, Jennifer Hillman, Petros Mavroidis, André Sapir, Rob Howse, Weihuan Zhou, and the present author. In “Governing the Interface of U.S.-China Trade Relations,” Gregory Shaffer offers refreshing insights. Building on the framework developed by the U.S.-China Trade Policy Working Group, of which he is a member, Shaffer further adjusts the group's “four-buckets” model and provides an updated framework. Calling his approach “Rebalancing Within a Multilateral Framework,” Shaffer argues that his framework avoids the pitfalls of both “Power-Based Bargaining” and “Rule-Based Neoliberalism” and is the most promising “middle path.” As a trade lawyer, I am naturally more inclined toward Shaffer's approach and its firmer grounding in trade law, in contrast to the heavily econ-centric approach in the Joint Statement by the Working Group, which does not reference law. Coming from the other side of the Pacific, however, I would approach the issue a bit differently by asking the questions that rarely gets asked: What are China's reactions to these proposals? Will China be willing to trail along, or, perhaps more likely, will it view them suspiciously as “traps,” as China's former World Trade Organization (WTO) Ambassador Zhang Xiangchen once put it?

A New Strategy of Foreign Economy and Trade Development in China on the Basis of Integrated Advantage Principle

Whether Comparative Advantage or Competitive Advantage

Path Selection for Rebuilding China's Trade Advantage:Perspective from Intra-industry Trade Theory

China's economic and trade development: Imbalance to equilibrium

Innovation,Dynamic Comparative Advantage,and Promotion of Economic Competitiveness

The Significance of Comparative Advantage Theory and Competitive Advantage Theory to the Development of China's Foreign Trade

The Trade Strategy and Policy in the World Economy:An Comparative Study from a Historical Perspective

Comparative Advantage and Economical Overtaking Strategy

China's Intra-product Trade: Status Quo Problems and Countermeasures

Re-examination of the Strategic Superiority of Our Country's Mid-western Part under the New Situations

The Strategy of China's Native Enterprises under the Circumstance of Globalization: a Theoretical Framework and Applied Analysis

RESEARCH ON INNOVATION-DRIVEN DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY , COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE AND INDUSTRIAL TRANSFORMATION AND UPGRANDING

The Problem in China's Out-gving Economic Develvpment Strategy and Corresponding Advice

RETRACTED: Chinese labor-intensive industries under trade protectionism – Characteristics, comprehensive strategies and educational revelations based on economic comparative advantage

Promising Trail or Perilous Trap? Engaging China in the WTO and Beyond

COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE AND FOREIGN TRADE DEVELOPMENT IN NORTHEAST AREA

Competitive and Comparative Advantage: Towards a Unified Theory of International Trade

China's Auto Industry Strategic Transforming from Comparative Advantage to Competitive Advantage

Sino-US trade war, the principle of competitive neutrality and the reform of China’s state-owned enterprises

Improve the Quality of Foreign Investments:Theoretical Analysis and Counter Strategy

Policies and Effects of the Advantages Integration in the Condition of Economic Catching-up