Comparative Study Between Big City and South Rural Populations by Using BMI and WC Screening Criteria

Cheng-ye JI
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16835/j.cnki.1000-9817.2010.04.002
2010-01-01
Abstract:Objective By comparing with the using of BMI screening criterion,to testimony the validity of the new setting WC cutoffs in screening the prevalence of childhood overweight and obesity in two Chinese subpopulations. Methods The two objective populations came from the coastal major city and south rural areas in which there are 27 256 and 40 270 subjects,respectively. They were 7-to 22-year-old primary,secondary and college students all of which were of Han. Both the BMI criterion and the WC cutoffs were used to screen overweight and obesity. The Resultsz of the two criteria were compared and the concordance between them was analyzed. Results The prevalence of overweight/obesity using the WC cutoffs were significantly higher than that screened out by the BMI criterion,and the concordance between the two criteria were quite low. The main factors for causing these disparities were resulted by the low WC cutoffs,with that of the obesity were more significant than that of the overweight,and more evident for the females than for the males. Significant higher overestimating rates were found in the south rural population than in the coastal city population,which were closely associated by the much inferior physical growth level of the former. Conclusion The thresholds of the WC criterion are needed to be raised in order to decrease the overestimated errors. Several measures for improving the validity and accuracy of the WC cutoffs are suggested.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?