Comparison of Two Obesity Criterions for Screening Obesity and Over-weight Among Students

郭亚文,姜庆五,何永频,陈毅琼,沈小夏
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare weight-for-height standard method in 1985 and the body mass index(BMI) "Reference Norm for Screening Overweight and Obesity in Chinese Children and Adolescents"(2003) for overweight and obesity screening in primary and middle school students.Methods Two screening criterions were carried out among 28 197 students aged 7-18 years in monitoring schools of Jing'an District from 2001 to 2007.Results The prevalence rates of obesity was lower by the BMI method compared to that by weight-for-height standard method,and they were 9.22% and 15.98% respectively.The consistent rate was from 55.68% to 59.33% in boys.The consistent rate was lower with the age in the boys.It was from 57.46% to 68.94% in girls.The rate of unable to be screened using weight-for-height standard method was 5.62%.The boys contributed to 95.46% of the total,and they were most in junior high school and high school students.The obese rate was higher in boys than in girls with two criterions.In boys,the obese rate was highest in primary school and lowest in high school using two screening criterions.In girls,it was the same as boys with BMI criteria.It was no difference between primary school and junior middle school in girls with the weight-for-height standard method.With the both criterions,the prevalence of obesity in primary and junior schools were higher than the high schools.Conclusion Weight-for-height standard which was established in 1985 is not correlated well with the obesity and overweight students.BMI criteria made by WGOC(2003) is more scientific than weight-for-height standard method(1985) in overweight and obesity screening in students,and in the study of the intervention of obesity and overweight.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?