A Saussure in the“Vise”of“Social”and“Individual”: Bakhtin's and Chomsky's Inheritances from and Criticisms of Saussure

Li Shuguang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16238/j.cnki.rla.2013.04.024
2013-01-01
Abstract:Though they both inherit a lot from Saussure,Bakhtin and Chomsky criticize him from opposing angles. Bakhtin agrees with Saussure on his social-semiotic construal of language,but between Saussure's langue and parole he regards the latter rather than the former as the firstorder reality of linguistics. Under the influence of Saussure,Chomsky proposed his dichotomy between competence and performance,but he chooses to observe human language from an individualistic perspective,regarding the states of the language organ in human brains as the first-order reality of language. In terms of discourse strategies,Bakhtin accepts Saussure's linguistic ideas through criticism,while Chomsky criticizes Saussure through showing affinity with him. Such differences result not only from their tasks of constructing their own characteristic theories but from the openness in the"social-psychological"framework of Saussure's synchronic linguistics as well.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?