Relationship Between Paternalistic Leadership and Organizational Learning: the Mediate Role of Human Resource Management Practice
Xiaoming Zheng
2012-01-01
Abstract:For Chinese enterprises,the organizational learning capacity is the most important core competitive in the future.But Chinese leaders don't know how to lead organizational learning.To date,there was limited systematic empirical research directly linking leadership and organizational learning.Recent theoretical work systematically linked transformational and transactional leadership with organizational learning.Only few empirical study explored the relationship between transformational leadership and organizational learning,and the results showed that transformational leadership could improve organizational leaning.The paternalistic leadership is based on the Chinese culture.However,there was no research to explore the effectiveness mechanism of the paternalistic leadership on organizational learning in the context of Chinese culture.And the management practice in China need to know what and how leadership could improve organizational leaning in order to improve their organizational core competitiveness One survey that contained organizational learning scale,paternalistic leadership scale,and human resource management practice scale was employed as the tool in the study.Among the major measures,the 33-item 3of paternalistic leadership scale was adopted from Zheng et al(2011);29-item organizational learning scale was measured by using the questionnaire of Yu Haibo et al(1991);19-item human resource management practice scale was developed by Lopez et al(1994)and Wright et al(2005).The reliability of Cronbach's alpha for these measures were all above 0.70.Four hundred and sixty one employees of thirteen enterprises from several cities in China answered the questionnaires.Exploratory factor analysis(EFA),confirmatory factor analysis(CFA) and structure equation model(SEM) were applied to the analysis of the data. The results of EFA showed that Human Resource Management Practice Questionnaire was composed of five factors: selection and employment,strategic training,compensation management,performance management,employee participation.And the results of CFA confirmed the five factors model.The results of SEM(structure equation model) showed that strategic training,compensation management,and employee participation were the total mediating variables between benevolence leadership and organizational learning.Strategic training and compensation management were the partial mediating variables between moral leadership and organizational learning.At last,Strategic training and compensation management were the total mediating variables between authoritarianism leadership and organizational learning.The results also showed that the effectiveness of moral leadership on organizational learning was the biggest one,the benevolence leadership was the second one,and the authoritarianism leadership was the smallest one. The main implication of the results was that paternalistic leadership could influence organizational learning through the mediating of human resource management,and also could directly influence organizational learning.The empirical study could enrich the theory of the leadership of organizational learning,especially the value of the paternalistic leadership in Chinese culture.And at the same time,the results suggested that the leaders,especial the Chinese paternalistic leaders,could improve the level of organizational learning through constructing and improving the organizational human resource management system.This suggests that human resource management system has great positive effectiveness on organizational long-term development in Chinese enterprises. In the future,research need to test the causal and mediating relationships longitudinally or by qualitative research.The complex relationships between paternalistic leadership and organizational learning could be constructed and tested according to the organizational culture and strategic human resources management theory.And the moderators in the relationships between paternalistic leadership and organizational learning should be explored deeply.At last,the complex mediating role of human resources management and organizational culture.so that paternalistic leaders could integrate organizational soft and hard to improve organizational capability.