“Best Practices” or “Best Fit”: Exploring the Effects of the HR Systems and Contexts on Outcomes
Meng Xi,Yan Chen,Yueyue Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2020.14324abstract
2020-01-01
Academy of Management Proceedings
Abstract:In the strategic human resource management (SHRM) field, there has been a classic debate regarding the “best-practice” versus “best-fit” approach to HRM. The present study aims to address this debate. Using a sample of 481 organizations representing a range of industries, we found that there are four types of HR systems, namely cost minimizers, commitment maximizers, motivation enhancers, and skill builders. Moreover, we found that various organizational contexts (i.e., firm ownership, employee-oriented organizational culture, local human resource supply, and local government-market relationship) and different types of HR systems interactively influence collective affective commitment and firm performance. The theoretical contributions and practical implications of these findings are discussed.