A Cross-Level Study of Relationships between Industrial Attributes, Pay Dispersion in Top Management Team and Firm Performance

Li Shaolong,Long Lirong,He Wei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2012.04.007
2012-01-01
Abstract:In the field of human resource management and corporate governance,the relationship between pay dispersion in the top management team(TMT) and firm performance is one of the hot topics,but has not yet been obtained unanimous conclusion.Based on the theories of tournament and social comparison,this article tries to use hierarchical linear models to analyze the relationships between top management team’s vertical pay dispersion,horizontal pay dispersion and firm performance,and explore the moderating effects of industrial attributes with the data of 992 Chinese listed companies from 39 industries.Results of multilevel analysis showed that:(1) vertical pay dispersion in top management team had a positive effect on firm performance;(2) TMT’s vertical and horizontal pay dispersion had an interactive effect on firm performance(3) variance of executive pay levels within the industry negatively moderated the relationship between TMT’s vertical pay dispersion and firm performance,while positively moderated the relationship between TMT’s horizontal pay dispersion and firm performance;(4) industrial technology intensity had a positive moderating effect on the relationship between TMT’s horizontal pay dispersion and firm performance.These findings highlighted the necessity of study on TMT pay dispersion and firm performance.Moreover,some significances and implications can be drawn from this study.First,this study extends the literature on the relationship between pay dispersion in the top management team and firm performance by integrating the tournament theory and social comparison theory.Second,this study has to a certain degree opened the black box of the relationship between TMT’s pay dispersion and firm performance by exploring the industrial moderators like variance of executive pay levels and technology intensity within the industry.Third,some theoretical and practical implications on how to design pay structure of TMT preferably in industries with different attributes were provided.Limitations and suggestions for future research are discussed at the end of the article.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?