Abstract:Rural geographies are often discounted as marginal to mainstream interests. In part this is because the rural is conflated with agricultural, and thereby is of significant but only minority interest; in part it is because rural geographers tend to be theory importers rather than theory exporters. This marginality is now changing, as rural life becomes variously the object of desire for increasing numbers of people in the Western world, and as critical rural geographies make use of political-economic and sociocultural theories to address issues of nature-society relations and discursive transformations of central concern to human geography as a whole. This paper uses the experience of undertaking a major research project on rural life-styles in England to address a number of such issues. I discuss how the notion of “problems” in rural life have been theorized and researched to date, focusing on the metaphor of “deprivation” as a key but unchallenging bridge between academic and policy discourses about the rural. Using research findings from a major survey of rural life-styles, I argue that both normative accounts of how opportunities are structured in rural areas and qualitative accounts of how rural life is experienced are crucial in a critical interpretation of changing rural life-styles. I suggest important methodological and interpretative implications of using this twin approach. Finally, I record the relations between researchers and the policymaking agencies that sponsored the research, noting how sociocultural emphases on difference are discordant with the simpler unitary narratives of problems preferred by such agencies, and how findings of different rural experiences are vulnerable to a response based on the politics of individual responsibility.

Rural Gatekeepers and 'greentrified' Pennine Rurality: Opening and Closing the Access Gates?

Socio-cultural representations of greentrified Pennine rurality

Rural Life-Styles: Material Opportunity, Cultural Experience, and How Theory Can Undermine Policy

Baroque rurality in an English village

Rural geography III: Marketing, mobilities, measurement and metanarratives

Holistic gentrification and the recreation of rurality: The new wave of rural gentrification in chengdu, China

Reconfiguring rural development in the UK: Objective 5b and the new rural governance

Counterurbanization, gentrification and the potential for rural revitalisation in China

Rural governance and local involvement: assessing state—community relations in the Scottish Highlands

The spatial implications of rural business digitalization: case studies from Wales

Political economy of the 'agrarian–urban frontier' in Pakistan: Agrarian transformation, social reproduction and exploitation

New Forms of Sub-regional Governance and Implications for Rural Areas: Evidence from England

Unequal futures of rural mobility: Challenges for a “Smart Countryside”

Urbanization without guarantees: articulation, rentier capitalism and occupancy on the agrarian urban frontier

Popular culture and what we make of the rural, with a case study of village allotments

Hospitality workers and gentrification processes: Elective belonging and reflexive complicity

Beyond Displacement: the Co-Existence of Newcomers and Local Residents in the Process of Rural Tourism Gentrification in China

Situating spatial justice in counter-urban lifestyle mobilities: relational rural theory in a time of crisis

Social, cultural and spatial imaginaries in rural tourism transitions

Changes in service provision in rural areas. Part 1: The use of GIS in analysing accessibility to services in rural deprivation research

The digital vicious cycle: Links between social disadvantage and digital exclusion in rural areas