Abstract:Rural geographies are often discounted as marginal to mainstream interests. In part this is because the rural is conflated with agricultural, and thereby is of significant but only minority interest; in part it is because rural geographers tend to be theory importers rather than theory exporters. This marginality is now changing, as rural life becomes variously the object of desire for increasing numbers of people in the Western world, and as critical rural geographies make use of political-economic and sociocultural theories to address issues of nature-society relations and discursive transformations of central concern to human geography as a whole. This paper uses the experience of undertaking a major research project on rural life-styles in England to address a number of such issues. I discuss how the notion of “problems” in rural life have been theorized and researched to date, focusing on the metaphor of “deprivation” as a key but unchallenging bridge between academic and policy discourses about the rural. Using research findings from a major survey of rural life-styles, I argue that both normative accounts of how opportunities are structured in rural areas and qualitative accounts of how rural life is experienced are crucial in a critical interpretation of changing rural life-styles. I suggest important methodological and interpretative implications of using this twin approach. Finally, I record the relations between researchers and the policymaking agencies that sponsored the research, noting how sociocultural emphases on difference are discordant with the simpler unitary narratives of problems preferred by such agencies, and how findings of different rural experiences are vulnerable to a response based on the politics of individual responsibility.

Reconfiguring rural development in the UK: Objective 5b and the new rural governance

New Forms of Sub-regional Governance and Implications for Rural Areas: Evidence from England

Mechanisms of Metagovernance As Structural Challenges to Levelling Up in England

Restructuring of Rural Governance in a Rapidly Growing Resource Town: The Case of Kitimat, BC, Canada

Rural governance and local involvement: assessing state—community relations in the Scottish Highlands

Rural Development: From Practices and Policies towards Theory

Distinct Types of Restructuring Scenarios for Rural Settlements in a Heterogeneous Rural Landscape: Application of a Clustering Approach and Ecological Niche Modeling

England's Catch-22: Institutional Limitations to Achieving Balanced Growth Through Devolution

Reframing rural planning

Rural Landscapes—Challenges and Solutions to Landscape Governance

Partnerships, Power, and Scale in Rural Governance

Rural Cohesion: Collective Efficacy and Leadership in the Territorial Governance of Inclusion

Rural governance, community empowerment and the new institutionalism: A case study of the Isle of Wight

Knowledge governance for sustainable rural development; exploring potentials, characteristics and barriers in the northern Frisian woodlands

Situated legitimacy: Deliberative arenas and the new rural governance

Rural Regional Governance in the United States: The Case of the Resource Conservation and Development Program*

Urban–rural interdependencies: Joining up policy in practice

Defining the limits of community governance

Rural Life-Styles: Material Opportunity, Cultural Experience, and How Theory Can Undermine Policy

Exceptional Spaces for Sustainable Living: The Regulation of One Planet Developments in the Open Countryside

The role of multi-actor governance in aligning farm modernization and sustainable rural development