Clinical Observation of Concurrent Chemoradiotherapy or Radiation Therapy in Treatment of Patients with Esophageal Carcinoma
Fan Yuwei,Qi Liwei,Jiang Xiaodong,Chen Nianchun,Li Jia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-5412.2009.06.013
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the effective power,local control rate and survival rate of 3DCRT or 3DCRT combined with concurrent chemotherapy in the treatment of patients with esophageal carcinoma.Methods We divided 89 patients with esophageal carcinoma into 3 groups.Concurrent chemoradiotherapy group(A): using 3DCRT,DT 60 Gy,meanwhile giving chemotherapy with DDP+5-Fu at the first and the fifth week.1-2 months later,to consolidate therapeutic effect by the same chemotherapy.3DCRT group(B): using 3DCRT,DT 60-70 Gy.Conventional radiotheraphy group(C): using conventional radiotherapy,DT 68-72 Gy.Results The effective power of A,B,C three groups was 92.86%,83.87%,80.00%,respectively(P>0.05);the one year control rate is 82.14%,77.42%,63.33%,respectively(P>0.05);the two year control rate was 71.43%,64.52%,46.67%,respectively(P<0.05);the three year control rate was 60.71%,45.16%,30.00%,respectively(P<0.05);the survival rate of the one year was 75.00%,67.74%,60.00%,respectively(P>0.05);the survival rate of the two year was 64.29%,51.62%,43.33%,respectively(P>0.05);the survival rate of the three years was 46.43%,41.94%,23.33%,respectively(P<0.05).Conclusion 3DCRT combined with concurrent chemotherapy and 3DCRT has better efficacy,as compared with the conventional radiotheraphy;3DCRT combined with concurrent chemotherapy has better efficacy,as compared with 3DCRT.