Perception of Pain Expression Among Surgical Patients and Families from Three Ethnic Groups of a Nation: A Multicenter Qualitative Study
Getu Hanago,Matthias Siebeck,Samuel Dira,Tefera Tadesse,Dominik Irnich
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/jpr.s447676
IF: 2.8319
2024-01-17
Journal of Pain Research
Abstract:Getu Ataro Hanago, 1 Matthias Siebeck, 2 Samuel Jilo Dira, 3 Tefera Tadesse, 4 Dominik Irnich 5 1 Department of Anesthesia, Hawassa University, Hawassa, Ethiopia; 2 Institute of Medical Education, LMU University Hospital, LMU Munich, Munich, Germany; 3 Department of Anthropology, Hawassa University, Hawassa, Ethiopia; 4 Institute of Educational Research, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia; 5 Multidiciplinary Pain Center, Department of Anesthesiology, LMU University Hospital LMU Munich, Munich, Germany Correspondence: Getu Ataro Hanago, Email Background: Despite its universal nature; perception, coping, responses, treatment options, and overall experiences of pain are influenced by biopsychosocial factors to various extents. Pain perception, expression, and control are progressively learned behaviors among members of a society and are culture-specific. Effects of ethnicity-related culture (ethnoculture) on pain experience in a broader context have increasingly been reported. However, evidence from ethnoculturally diverse groups of a nation, particularly based on surgical patients, is limited. Therefore, as a qualitative research effort of a broader project aimed at assessing ethnocultural determinants of surgical pain management, this study explored the perception of ethnoculturally diverse patients and families about expressing surgical disease-related pain. Methods: This study follows subjectivist-interpretivist philosophical assumptions as an underpinning research paradigm. We purposively selected 11 patients for in-depth interviews and 12 patients' family members for focus group discussions in three hospitals of ethnic-based regions of Ethiopia. In the phenomenological frame, thematic analysis was employed. Finding: Ethnocultural background influences how individuals express and respond to pain according to emergent themes of finding— Pain and overlooked cultural influence, Pain expressiveness in cultural context, Stereotypes of pain expressiveness, and Bravehood through stoic response . Pain feelings are commonly hidden where the domestic culture values stoic response to pain compared to ethnoculture where pain expressiveness is encouraged. Conclusion: Individuals can express and respond to pain differently due to ethnocultural diversity within a nation. Researchers and clinicians should consider cultural context while applying the prevailing one-size-fits-all pain assessment tools among surgical patients of a nation with ethnocultural diversity. Keywords: surgical pain, pain and culture, pain expression, pain behavior, pain response, stoic response Pain is a ubiquitous and universal phenomenon that everyone— from society with diverse cultures and human social development stages— can experience in a lifetime. Despite its universal nature, pain-related perception, coping, responses, treatment options, and overall experiences are affected by biological, psychological, and social factors. 1,2 Fairly long after the inception of the Gate Control Theory of pain, 3 a six-dimensional view of pain— namely, physiologic, sensory, affective, cognitive, behavioral, and socio-cultural dimensions— emerged about two decades ago. 4 Of all, the socio-cultural dimension of pain has got increased attention for the past few years. As clearly described in the definition by the International Association for Study of Pain (IASP), 5 pain is not just an anatomical, physiological, or pathological entity, rather it is a phenomenon we find at the intersection of body, mind, and culture. 6,7 The way one's pain perception, expression, and control are progressively learned behaviors of members of a society and, hence, it is culture-specific. 8 Sensation, perception, and coping strategies for pain are different across cultural groups. 9 People in ethnic groups of distinct cultures express and cope with pain differently. Whereas those patients who consider pain as a private and personal experience prefer to cope with pain by turning inward, others express verbally, crying and screaming. 9 Expressed or "turned inward", untreated persistent pain results in overwhelming morbidity and compromised quality of life. 10 Differences in pain perception and coping strategy may not be merely confined to cultural differences among nations of two or more continents, regions, or countries as shown in several studies; there are also disparities across culture and ethnic groups of a single nation. 11,12 Ethnicity and culture are too complex social constructs to define in simple sentences and vary with the contexts in which the terms a -Abstract Truncated-
clinical neurology