Internal and External Transcendence:Religious Beliefs,Moral Beliefs and Order

Ren Jiantao
2012-01-01
Social Sciences in China
Abstract:Both the famous thinker Mou Zongsan and the historian Yu Yingshi believe that the uniqueness of Confucianism lies in its "internal transcendence," which is fundamentally different from the "external transcendence" of Christianity.If we analyze this statement,we see that it arose from the religious and political pressures placed on Confucianism by Christianity.Traditional Confucianism does not pursue transcendence either in the religious or in the ontological-epistemological sense.In contrast to the religious transcendence that highlights the relationship between God and man and the ontological-epistemological transcendence that emphasizes the transcendental-experiential structure,Confucianism is an ethical system that attaches great importance to the cultivation of virtue and enhancement of the human realm.In the modern context,it would seem unnecessary to cite the religious nature of Confucianism in defense of Confucian values.However,in terms of the psycho-social order essential to a socio-political community,Confucianism stresses orderly arrangements based on moral beliefs.In this way,Confucianism plays a similar role to Christianity in satisfying the people and strengthening social cohesion.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?