Comparison of Two Operations for Spontaneous Pneumothorax in Middle-Aged or Elderly Patients

Wang Keyi,Yan Tiansheng,Liu Dandan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6604.2008.02.014
2008-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the clinical value of 2 operations for spontaneous pneumothorax in middle-aged or elderly patients. Methods From November 1997 to January 2007, 38 middle-aged or elderly patients with unilateral spontaneous pneumothorax were treated with bullectomy and pleurodesis in our department. Among the cases, minithoracotomy was performed on 20, and video-assisted thoracic surgery was carried out in 18. Results Both the operations were completed successfully in the two groups without intraoperative mortality or serious complications. The cost of minithoracotomy group was significantly lower than that in the video-assisted thoracic surgery group [ (1593.4±411.0) yuan vs (2357.2±255.8) yuan, t= 6.786, P=0.000]. Whereas, the postoperative hospital stay in the minithoracotomy group was significantly longer than that in the video-assisted thoracic surgery group [(14.4±14.1) d vs (9.0±8.2) d, U=95.500, P=0.012]. No significant difference was observed between the two groups in operation time, analgesic requirement (pethidine), and arterial oxygen tension and carbon dioxide tension in the first postoperative day (P>0.05). Sixteen patients in the video-assisted thoracic surgery group were followed up for a mean of 42.9 months (20-88 months), during which no recurrence was detected. In the minithoracotomy group, 18 patients received an 18-to 71-month follow-up (mean, 41.2 months), none of them had recurrence. Conclusions The outcomes of both the operations are satisfying for middle-aged or elderly patients with spontaneous pneumothorax. However, video-assisted thoracic surgery should be the first choice.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?