Plato's Criticism to the Conception of Justice of Utilitarianism and Its Modern Theoretical Response
WANG Xiao-chao,CHEN Yue-hua
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-7071.2011.04.008
2011-01-01
Abstract:Plato discusses on justice more than other ancient Greek philosophers.His Republic is a classical work on justice.In this work,Plato summarizes the conception of justice of Utilitarianism that it defines the essence of justice as "benefit" and traces the origin of justice back to a contract for seeking advantages and avoiding disadvantages.Then he criticizes such a view,because(1) it advocates people to pursuit injustice for benefits,(2) it misplaces the justice of virtue and wisdom,(3) with disruption,hatred and conflict,it will destroy the happiness of the injustice.However,Plato believes that it is only by seeking the true essence of justice that we can refute such view.Finally,this article reviews the commentaries from MacIntyre,Cassirer and Leo Strauss,and regards Plato's theory of justice as "Essentialism" or "Holism".