Humanity (Ren) Overrides Sovereignty——On Mencius’s View of a Just War

Bai Tongdong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0257-5833.2013.01.014
2013-01-01
Journal of Social Sciences
Abstract:The starting point of Mencius’s theory of a just war is humanity (ren, also translated as benevolence). According to it, whether a defensive or an aggressive war is just depends upon the principle that "humanity overrides sovereignty." Mencius specifies detailed conditions and signs for a war to be considered just, and he explains his understanding of the relations between humane governance and the strength of a state. These ideas demonstrate the realistic side of Mencius, a Confucian who is commonly considered (overly?) idealistic. There are similarities and, more importantly, differences between Mencius’s theory of a just war and the Western main stream theory that advocates "human rights override sovereignty." It will be shown that Mencius’s idea of "humanity overrides sovereignty" offers a new and better alternative to mainstream Western theories of a just war and international relations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?