Flexible Verdicts——One Kind of Judicial Verdicts which are Worthy of Reflection

CHEN Rui-hua
2010-01-01
Abstract:With the disclosure of some criminal false judgments, flexible verdicts have gradually captured public attentions recently. The basic characteristics of this kind of verdicts are "presumed guilty until proven innocent" and "imposing a lenient sentence if be presumed guilty", which also mean that courts will make a guilty verdict and impose a lenient sentence although the standards of guilty verdicts are not yet satisfied. In terms of the judicial system and judicial procedure, the reasons for this kind of verdicts are complex. Under the influence of them, Chinese courts can’t become the vindicator of justice, but only to survive by compromise due to the judicial idea of realism. However, after the disclosure of many "cases in which people were unjustly, falsely or wrongly charged", courts often become the victims of system. So long as this kind of judicial manner still exists, judicial credibility of courts will never be established and the criminal judicial system won’t have any substantial change definitely.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?