The Future of Philosophy in China: A Intercommunion and Interaction of Chinese and Western and Marxist Philosophy
林安梧,欧阳康,邓晓芒,郭齐勇
2007-01-01
Abstract:Lin Anwu emphasizes that the study of Chinese and Western philosophy should not run into the trap of "essentialism". For example, we can’t say that Chinese have no free will, because the Confucianists of Pre Qing Dynasty do attach importance to free will, which was just worn out by later generations. Lin put forward a "methodological conventionalism", claiming to return to the classical text by means of the "5 Arguments", and let Chinese culture play the part of adjustment in learning democracy and science, which is called "Post-New-Confucianism". Ouyang Kang reckons that the essence of philosophy is dialogue. Nevertheless, the monopoly of Marxism is found accountable for the barrier to dialogues of philosophies in China. The greatest improvement in Chinese philosophy after 1978 was recovery of philosophy essence, after which it stepped into the road of dialogue,and Marxist philosophy in China processed its own academic orientation, which had a merit over western Marxism. But a continued opening and equality were still demanded. Deng Xiaomang suggests that the essentialism is in fact rational spirit, which is a platform for every dialogue. Though all ages, China lacked this essentialism, not to say anti-essentialism. Confucian liberalism is superficial appearance, because essentially it does not respect free will, but offer chosen items (like Tian-tao) for them to choose. These become all obscure without essentialism. Guo Qiyong holds that the essence of philosophy is most importantly cosmologic ultimate thought, which is the platform of communication between western and Chinese philosophy. Not only Chinese Tian-tao, but also God in western Christianity and "the starry heavens above me and the moral law within me" of Kant, are preconditions of free will. In spite of ration, "intellectual intuition" is more important, which is the knowledge of life and practice, having much in common with Marxist praxis-philosophy.