Meniscal Allograft Sizing by the Measurement of the Meniscus and Tibial Plateau——A Cadaveric Study

Luo Hao,Gong Xi,Chen Lianxu,Jiang Dong,Wang Haijun,Zhang Jiying,Yu Jiakuo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-6710.2012.02.005
2012-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the relationship between the size of meniscus and tibial plateau and to estimate the feasibility of calculating the accurate size of meniscus from the size of tibial plateau.Methods Sixteen fresh frozen cadaveric knees,aged 25 to 45 years,were dissected.There were 8 left knees and 8 right knees.The width and the length of the medial and lateral meniscus,the medial and lateral tibial plateau were measured.The measured data(mean ± standard deviation) were statistically evaluated and compared.The linear regression analysis was applied for each pair of data of the meniscus and the tibial plateau.According to this linear relationship,the theoretic size of the meniscus could be calculated by the size of the tibial plateau,and then the theoretic size and the actually measured size of the meniscus were compared.The accuracy was defined as the error of those theoretic sizes that fell within 5% of the actual sizes.The number of accurate theoretic size of the meniscus in every item could be obtained.Results The width of the medial meniscus(WMM) and the medial tibial plateau(WMT) were(29.2±2.1)mm and(33.8±2.1)mm(P < 0.001),respectively.The length of the medial meniscus(LMM) and the medial tibial plateau(LMT) were 39.8±4.1mm and(50.6±2.0)mm(P < 0.001),respectively.And the width of the lateral meniscus(WLM) and the lateral tibial plateau(WLT) were(30.9±2.2)mm and(33.7±1.6)mm(P < 0.001),respectively.The length of the lateral meniscus(LLM) and the lateral tibial plateau(LLT) were(33.3±2.5)mm and(46.8±2.5)mm(P < 0.001),respectively.Although there were correlations between WMM and WMT,LMM and LMT,WLM and WLT,LLM and LLT,the accuracy for the derived linear regression formulas was 50%,31.25%,75%,56.25%,respectively.Conclusion The theoretic size of meniscus calculated by the size of tibial plateau is not accurate.Consequently,it is not feasible to obtain the accurate size of the meniscus from the size of the tibial plateau when sizing for allograft meniscus transplantation.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?