Comparative study on retroperitoneal laparoscopy and open renal cyst unroofing in the treatment of simple renal cysts and polycystic kidney
Guo-fang ZHAO,Min LI,Zhi-bin LI,Chun-ting YANG,Yi HU,Xiao-hua WAN,Dong-ling DU,Yao-long YAN,Wei-fei CAI
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-6575.2010.03.003
2010-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the advantage of retroperitoneal laparoscopy and open renal cyst unroofing in treatment of simple renal cysts and adult polycystic kidney,and to investigate the indications of retroperitoneal laparoscopy renal cyst unroofing.Methods Clinical data of renal cyst unroofing of 26 simple renal cysts cases(Group A1)and 8 adult polycystic kindney disease(ADPKD)cases(Group B1) by using retroperitoneal laparoscopy,and 29 cases simple renal cysts(Group A2) and 10 cases ADPKD(Group B2) by open renal cyst unroofing were retrospectively analyzed.Results Both methods could get similar effect in the treatment of simple renal cysts and ADPKD.The operation time,the intraoperative bleeding volume,the complications during and after operation,the postoperative activity out of bed,the postoperative painkiller used,the indwelling drainage tube time,the fasting time,the postoperative hospital stay and the reduction rate of the retroperitoneal laparoscopy group(Group A1 and Group B1)were better than those of the open surgical group(Group A2 and Group B2)(P<0.01).Conclusion Retroperitoneal laparoscopy renal cyst unroofing were superior to open renal cyst unroofing,suggesting it as the first choice in surgical treatment for simple renal cysts and ADPKD.