Comparison of the effects of atologous bone marrow mononuclear cells implantation in treating 94 patients with chronic lower limb ischemia at different stages
Gu Yong-quan,Zhang Jian,Qi Li-xing,Guo Lian-rui,Wang Zhong-gao,ShuWen Zhang,Li Jian-xin,Xu Juan,Su Li,Ji Bing-xin,Yu Heng-xi,Li Xue-feng,Cui Shi-jun,Luo Tao,Wu Xin,Dong Zong-jun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1673-8225.2005.38.001
2005-01-01
Abstract:AIM: To observe the therapeutic effects of autologous bone marrow mononuclear cells implantation on chronic lower limb ischemia at the stages of intermintternt claudication, rest pain, ulcer and gangrene. METHODS: From March 2003 to February 2005, 102 diseased limbs were selected from 94 patients with lower extremity ischemia (59 males and 35 females) with an average age of 69.5 years, who were treated in the Xuanwu Hospital, Capital University of Medical Sciences. Of the diseased limbs, 90 were caused by diabetic lower limb ischemia (n=84), 7 by atherosclerotic occlusion (n=6), and 5 by thromboangiitis obliterans (n=4); 13 were at the stage of intermintternt claudication (n=12) and 41 at rest pain (n=38), the stage of tissue damage included ulcer (26 diseased limbs, n=24) and gangrene (22 diseased limbs, n=20). ① All the received autologous bone marrow mononuclear cells implantation, the methods of lower limb local intramuscular injection, lower limb arterial intracavitary injection and the lower limb local intramuscular injection together with lower limb arterial intracavitary injection. Lower limb local intramuscular injection was to inject the isolated and purified autologous bone marrow mononuclear cells into the muscles at the ischemic sites of the diseased limbs by means of multiple points. Lower limb arterial intracavitary injection was to inject the bone marrow mononuclear cells into the arterial cavity of lower limbs, and the proximal blood flow at the occluded site of lower limb artery should be blocked with Foley's tube for 3-5 minutes. The method of lower limb local intramuscular injection together with lower limb arterial intracavitary injection was to implant by using the above two methods at the same time. ② Evaluation of the main clinical symptoms and subjective indexes of physical signs: According to the walking distance under normal velocity, the stage of intermintternt claudication was divided into 5 grades, which were grade 0: walking distance ≥ 500 m as painless; grade 1: walking distance of 400-499 m as painful; grade 2: walking distance of 300-399 m as painful; grade 3: walking distance of 100-299 m as painful; grade 4: could not walk or walking distance < 100 m as painful. According to painful or painless and severity of pain, the stage of rest pain was divided into 5 grades, which were grade 0: painless; grade 1: felt painful occasionally, could remember when being asked; grade 2: always felt painful but tolerable, common analgesic was not needed or needed occasionally; grade 3: common analgesic was always needed; grade 4: sleep was affected by the pain, and hard to be relieved by common analgesic. According to the existence of cold feeling or not and the severity of cold feeling, the cold feeling of the diseased limbs was divided into 5 grades, which were grade 0: no cold feeling; grade 1: the diseased limbs felt coldness and dreadful of cold weather occasionally; grade 2 the diseased limbs always felt cold and be dreadful of cold weather; grade 3: the diseased limbs felt coldness and dreadful of cold weather obviously, and could be relieved after measures of local warmth keeping; grade 4 the diseased limbs felt coldness and dreadful of cold weather obviously, and had no obvious amelioration after measures of local warmth keeping. ③ Evaluation of the main clinical symptoms and objective indexes of physical signs: The newly formed collateral vessels were classified as 4 grades according to their number, which were grade 0: no new collateral vessel; grade 1: a bit of new collateral vessels; grade 2: moderate amount of new collateral vessels; grade 3: plenty of new collateral vessels. The rate of limb-salvage took 2 months after implantation as the standard, and the rate of limb amputation and rate of limb-salvage at the stages were observed. ④ Evaluation of the therapeutic effects: No relief of pain, cold feeling and intermintternt claudication of diseased limb was taken as no change, grade 1 relief as improvement, grade 2 or 3 relief as obvious improvement, grade 0 as disappearance of symptoms; Healing of wounded surface and disappearance was taken as healing, decreased size of wounded surface as improvement, no change or amplification of wounded surface and pain as invalid. RESULTS: According to intention-to-treat analysis, all the 102 diseased limbs of the 94 patients were involved in the analysis of results. ① Comparison of the total effective rate of lower limb ischemia at different stages: The total effective rate was 100%, 92.7%, 83.3% and 59.1% at the stages of intermintternt claudication, rest pain, ulcer and gangrene respectively, it was close at the first 3 stages (χ2=1.01-2.23, P > 0.05), and there were no differences between the stages of rest pain and ucler (χ2 =1.11, P > 0.05), significantly higher at the first 3 stages than at the stage of gangrene (χ2=10.48, P < 0.01; χ2=5.18, P < 0.05; χ2=3.93, P < 0.05). ② Changes of ankle brachial index at different stages: The ankle brachial index increased by 46.2%, 31.7%, 34.6% and 27.3% at the stages of intermintternt claudication, rest pain, ulcer and gangrene respectively without t obvious differences.③ The rate of limb-salvage at different stages: The rate of limb-salvage was 100%, 97.6%, 88.5% and 59.1% at the stages of intermintternt claudication, rest pain, ulcer and gangrene respectively, it was close at the first 3 stages (χ2=0.32-0.41, P > 0.05), and there were no differences between the stages of rest pain and ucler (χ2=2.35, P > 0.05), significantly higher at the first 3 stages than at the stage of gangrene (χ2=15.87, P < 0.01; χ2=5.18, P < 0.05;χ2=5.48, P< 0.05). ④ The increase of transcutaneous oxygen pressure and angiogenesis at different stages: There was no obvious difference in the transcutaneous oxygen pressure among the stages. The arteriography of lower limb showed that the percentage of rich angiogenesis also had no obvious difference among the stages. CONCLUSION: Of the patients with lower limb ischemia treated with autologous bone marrow mononuclear cells implantation by means of local intramuscular injection of lower limb, the total effective rate and rate of limb-salvage had no obvious differences at the early, middle and ucler stages, which were all obviously higher than those at the late stage, it is fully indicated that autologous bone marrow mononuclear cells implantation is suitable especially for the patients with lower limb ischemia at the early and middle stages, and its therapeutic effect on late ischemia especially those with tissue gangrene of diseased limb still needs further improvement.