Towards the End of “red Envelopes” in China?
Ke-Jia Hu,Wen-Dong Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(14)61083-7
2014-01-01
Abstract:In an effort to improve hospitals and tackle bribery, patients and doctors are required from May 1, 2014, to sign mutually agreed contracts forbidding giving or receiving of so-called red envelopes.1National Health and Family Planning Commission of PRCDoctors and patients should sign contracts agreeing not to exchange or accept “red envelopes” in medical work (in Chinese).http://www.moh.gov.cn/yzygj/s3577/201402/b7f939aeaeee41c28ba80023b74c4187.shtmlGoogle Scholar This follows a circular released on Feb 20, by the National Health and Family Planning Commission, and reinforces the message that doctors can no longer rely on such channels for their income. Will this measure ensure ethical medical practice?Called “hongbao” in Putonghua and “laisee” in Cantonese, red envelopes (informal financial transactions) between patients and doctors are frequent in China. In large hospitals, with quality medical equipment and experienced doctors, consultation times are drastically shortened and doctor–patient communication neglected, so some patients give red envelopes with the hope to receive better medical treatment.According to the 1998 Medical Practitioner Law,2Department of Medical AdministrationNational Health and Family Planning CommissionMedical practitioner law (in Chinese).http://www.moh.gov.cn/mohyzs/s3580/200804/18250.shtmlGoogle Scholar doctors are not allowed to ask for, or illegally accept, money or other benefits from patients. Those who violate the law could receive a warning from health authorities, be suspended from medical practice for 6–12 months, or have their medical licences revoked.Both doctors and patients should be blamed for the use of red envelopes in medical practice. Banning red envelopes is just curing the symptoms, not the disease. The Chinese Government has been implementing reforms in an effort to increase medical investment, develop the medical care insurance system, distribute medical resources reasonably, and improve grading and referral systems to solve the difficulties and high cost of access to medical services in China.To strengthen doctors' professionalism, welfare and wages should be improved and drug-selling profits should be forbidden. Only then can we improve the patient–doctor relationship in China.We declare no competing interests. In an effort to improve hospitals and tackle bribery, patients and doctors are required from May 1, 2014, to sign mutually agreed contracts forbidding giving or receiving of so-called red envelopes.1National Health and Family Planning Commission of PRCDoctors and patients should sign contracts agreeing not to exchange or accept “red envelopes” in medical work (in Chinese).http://www.moh.gov.cn/yzygj/s3577/201402/b7f939aeaeee41c28ba80023b74c4187.shtmlGoogle Scholar This follows a circular released on Feb 20, by the National Health and Family Planning Commission, and reinforces the message that doctors can no longer rely on such channels for their income. Will this measure ensure ethical medical practice? Called “hongbao” in Putonghua and “laisee” in Cantonese, red envelopes (informal financial transactions) between patients and doctors are frequent in China. In large hospitals, with quality medical equipment and experienced doctors, consultation times are drastically shortened and doctor–patient communication neglected, so some patients give red envelopes with the hope to receive better medical treatment. According to the 1998 Medical Practitioner Law,2Department of Medical AdministrationNational Health and Family Planning CommissionMedical practitioner law (in Chinese).http://www.moh.gov.cn/mohyzs/s3580/200804/18250.shtmlGoogle Scholar doctors are not allowed to ask for, or illegally accept, money or other benefits from patients. Those who violate the law could receive a warning from health authorities, be suspended from medical practice for 6–12 months, or have their medical licences revoked. Both doctors and patients should be blamed for the use of red envelopes in medical practice. Banning red envelopes is just curing the symptoms, not the disease. The Chinese Government has been implementing reforms in an effort to increase medical investment, develop the medical care insurance system, distribute medical resources reasonably, and improve grading and referral systems to solve the difficulties and high cost of access to medical services in China. To strengthen doctors' professionalism, welfare and wages should be improved and drug-selling profits should be forbidden. Only then can we improve the patient–doctor relationship in China. We declare no competing interests.