Abstract:BackgroundChina launched a nationwide health-care reform in 2009. An important objective of the reform was to improve the health-care service quality by encouraging the entry and development of private hospitals and instilling market competition. The reform has led to a large increase in private hospitals, yet the effect on the hospital market and health-care service quality has not been systematically studied. This study evaluates the effect of the increase of private hospitals on the operations and health-care service quality of incumbent hospitals, and further explores differential responses to market competition between private and public hospitals.MethodsWe obtained administrative hospital panel data from the annual report of medical and health institutions in Chengdu, Sichuan province, China. The data are collected by the National Health and Family Planning Commission and cover all hospitals in Chengdu from 2007 to 2016. We excluded hospitals that recorded zero or missing values for either total revenue or total patient visits. The sample included a total of 603 hospitals, of which 208 were public hospitals. We used fixed-effects estimation by controlling for fixed effects of hospital, year, and district-by-year. We investigated six categories of outcome variables (hospital revenue, patient visits, the number of medical staff, mean yearly hospital expenditure, the number of medical devices, and inpatient mortality rate) and their subcategories. The independent variable was the ratio of the number of new private hospitals in a 10 km radius in a given year to the number of existing hospitals in a 10 km radius in the base year (2007). This variable measures the increase in intensity of competition from private hospital entries to the local hospital market.FindingsWhen the ratio of the number of private hospital entries to existing hospitals increased by 100%, there was a decrease in total revenue of (21·4%, p<0·0001) and patient visits to (23·7%, p<0·0001) incumbent private hospitals. By contrast, for incumbent public hospitals, total revenue only decreased by 1·3% (p=0·839) and patient visits increased by 1·6% (p=0·826). Furthermore, private hospitals cut total expenditure by 18·9% (p<0·0001). Specifically, the number of medical staff decreased by 4·8% (p=0·015) and total wage expenditure decreased by 13·5% (p=0·013). By contrast, public hospitals raised the number of medical staff by 5·3% (p=0·092) and increased the number of medical devices by 14·9% (p=0·048). Finally, inpatient mortality rate decreased in public hospitals by 3·43 deaths per 1000 admissions (p=0·001). By contrast, inpatient mortality rate decreases by 0·119 deaths per 1000 admissions (p=0·855) in private hospitals.InterpretationThe results show that the 2009 health-care reform has intensified hospital competition. Private and public hospitals respond differently to more intense competition: private hospitals reduce expenditure, whereas public hospitals raise health-care service quality. Our findings suggest that future pro-competition reforms need to consider differential responses to market competition between private and public hospitals.FundingJY acknowledges financial support from the Singapore Ministry of Education Academic Research Fund (no. FY2018-FRC3-006).

Supply-induced demand for medical services under price regulation: Evidence from hospital expansion in China

Deregulation and Pricing of Medical Services A Policy Experiment Based in China

Impacts of Price Changes on Public Hospital Reforms in China: Evidence from 25 Million Patients at Tertiary Hospitals.

Intended and Unintended Impacts of Price Changes for Drugs and Medical Services: Evidence from China.

Does Medical Equipment Expansion Lead to More Diagnostic Services? Evidence from China’s Sichuan Province

Hospital Response to Increases in Prices of Pediatric Services: Evidence from China

Is Universal and Uniform Health Insurance Better for China? Evidence from the Perspective of Supply-Induced Demand.

Differential Responses to Market Competition by Private and Public Hospitals in China: a Longitudinal Analysis

New evidence on supplier-induced demand in China's public tertiary hospitals: is the cost of hospitalization higher in the off-season?

Physician-Induced Demand: Evidence from China’s Drug Price Zero-Markup Policy

The effects of increased market competition on hospital services in Shandong and Henan Provinces

Impact of China's Public Hospital Reform on Healthcare Expenditures and Utilization: A Case Study in ZJ Province

The impacts and unintended consequences of the nationwide pricing reform for drugs and medical services in the urban public hospitals in China

The medical arms race and its impact in Chinese hospitals: implications for health regulation and planning

Does hospital competition lead to medical equipment expansion? Evidence on the medical arms race

Rapid growth of private hospitals in China: emerging challenges and opportunities to health sector management

Differential effect of China's Zero Markup Drug Policy on provider-induced demand in secondary and tertiary hospitals

Unintended effect of reduced patient cost sharing: evidence from China

Intended and unintended impacts of the comprehensive reform of urban public hospitals: A mixed-method study in Hangzhou, China

Control Costs, Enhance Quality, and Increase Revenue in Three Top General Public Hospitals in Beijing, China

Effects of Chinese medical pricing reform on the structure of hospital revenue and healthcare expenditure in county hospital: an interrupted time series analysis