The Major Topics and Disputes in Western Theories of Human Nature:with a Comparison Between Chinese and Western Theories of Human Nature
Fang Zhaohui
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0257-0289.2022.05.015
2022-01-01
Abstract:The term “human nature” originates from the ancient Greek word ■, referring to the whole process of growth with connection to the ancient Greek cosmology in earlier period. However, since 17 th century, this term has acquired several new senses such as（1） the common features of all human being;（2） given rather than man-made;（3） non-changeable by human will. These senses are quite closed to the basic senses of the term renxing in ancient Chinese texts. Since Kant defined the term “human nature” on basis of the distinction between nature and freedom, between experience and transcendence as well as between phenomenon and essence, his conception of human nature has shaped the usage of this term in the West to a large degree after him. There are varieties of schools of human nature in the West, including the classic metaphysical theories, the theory about the state of nature, the Christian theories of human being, modern/contemporary philosophy, the theories of human nature in modern social/natural sciences（such as sociology, psychology, behavior science, linguistics, biology, etc.）. The major topics/disputes of human nature in the West might be the discussions about（1） empirical or transcendental dimensions;（2） if or not human nature exists;（3） if or not human nature is changeable;（4） if or not human nature is good;（5） the essential parts of human nature. While there are many similarities between Chinese and Western theories of human nature（for example, the human nature is empirical or transcendental）, the biggest differences might be seen by the following phenomena: the traditional Chinese theory of human nature takes the moral lives as its major topic and focuses on if human nature is good or not; however, the Western theories of human nature tend to take the objective knowledge of human nature as its major pursuit, the good-evil problem of human nature has not been the central topic in the West except in Christianity, theory of the state of nature as well as in Kant’s moral philosophy.