Abstract:Tandem mass spectrometry has been the principal method in shotgun proteomics for peptide and protein identification. However, incorrect identifications reported by proteome search engines are still unknown, and further validation methods are needed. We have proposed a validation method pValid before, but its scope of application is limited because two features used in pValid are related to open database search and sub-optimal peptide candidates for tandem mass spectra, and the performance on complex datasets still has room for improvement. In this study, we developed a more comprehensive validation method, pValid 2, to break these limitations by removing the two features and bringing in a new feature related to the retention time predicted by a deep learning-based method pPredRT. pValid 2 yielded an average false positive rate of 0.03% and an average false negative rate of 1.37% on three testing datasets, better than those of pValid, and flagged 8.47% to 11.31% more incorrect identifications than pValid on two complex datasets. Moreover, pValid 2 flagged almost all decoy identifications in validating the open-search datasets. In addition, the function of validating identifications given by MaxQuant and MS-GF+ was implemented in pValid 2, and the validation results showed that pValid 2 performed dramatically better than three metabolic labeling validation methods. Further considering its cost-effectiveness as a pure computational approach, pValid 2 has the potential to be a widely used validation tool for peptide identifications of any proteome search engines in shotgun proteomics. SIGNIFICANCE: Identification results given by shotgun proteomics are vital to life science research. The correctness of identifications deeply affects the precision of the subsequent studies about protein structures and functions, protein-protein interactions, pathogenic mechanism, and targeted drugs. Thus, validating the correctness of identifications is crucial and urgent. In 2019, we developed an identification credibility validation method named pValid, whose false positive rate (FPR) is 0.03% and false negative rate (FNR) is 1.79%, comparable to those of the gold standard, i.e., the Synthetic-peptide validation method. However, pValid can only be used for validating the results from pFind, and its validation performance on a few complex datasets still has room for improvement. So, in this submission, we proposed pValid 2, a more comprehensive computational validation method that can validate identifications from any proteome search engines with increased discriminating power.

Bayesian Nonparametric Model for the Validation of Peptide Identification in Shotgun Proteomics

ProteinInferencer: Confident protein identification and multiple experiment comparison for large scale proteomics projects

Improving the Sensitivity of MASCOT Search Results Validation by Combining New Features with Bayesian Nonparametric Model

Binomial probability distribution model-based protein identification algorithm for tandem mass spectrometry utilizing peak intensity information.

pValid 2: A deep learning based validation method for peptide identification in shotgun proteomics with increased discriminating power

A Nonparametric Model for Quality Control of Database Search Results in Shotgun Proteomics

BPDA - A Bayesian Peptide Detection Algorithm for Mass Spectrometry

Spectrum Identification using a Dynamic Bayesian Network Model of Tandem Mass Spectra

Protein Probabilities in Shotgun Proteomics: Evaluating Different Estimation Methods Using A Semi-Random Sampling Model

Bpda2d-A 2d Global Optimization-Based Bayesian Peptide Detection Algorithm for Liquid Chromatograph-Mass Spectrometry

Bayesian Peptide Peak Detection for High Resolution TOF Mass Spectrometry

A novel framework to quantify uncertainty in peptide-tandem mass spectrum matches with application to nanobody peptide identification

Faster graphical model identification of tandem mass spectra using peptide word lattices

An SVM Scorer for More Sensitive and Reliable Peptide Identification Via Tandem Mass Spectrometry.

Comparative analysis of MS/MS search algorithms in label-free shotgun proteomics for monitoring host-cell proteins using trapped ion mobility and ddaPASEF

Bayesian nonparametric models for peak identification in MALDI-TOF mass spectroscopy

Test-Time Training for Deep MS/MS Spectrum Prediction Improves Peptide Identification.

A likelihood-based scoring method for peptide identification using mass spectrometry

Peptide Selection for Accurate Targeted Protein Quantification Via a Dimethylation High-Resolution Mass Spectrum Strategy with a Peptide Release Kinetic Model

Bayesian Peak Detection for Pro-TOF MS MALDI Data

A Nonlinear Scoring Framework for Peptide Identification via Tandem Mass Spectrometry