Abstract:Monitoring the progress of student learning is an important part of teachers' data-based decision making. One such tool that can equip teachers with information about students' learning progress throughout the school year and thus facilitate monitoring and instructional decision making is learning progress assessments. In practical contexts and research, estimating learning progress has relied on approaches that seek to estimate progress either for each student separately or within overarching model frameworks, such as latent growth modeling. Two recently emerging lines of research for separately estimating student growth have examined robust estimation (to account for outliers) and Bayesian approaches (as opposed to commonly used frequentist methods). The aim of this work was to combine these approaches (i.e., robust Bayesian estimation) and extend these lines of research to the framework of linear latent growth models. In a sample of N = 4970 second-grade students who worked on the quop-L2 test battery (to assess reading comprehension) at eight measurement points, we compared three Bayesian linear latent growth models: (a) a Gaussian model, (b) a model based on Student's t-distribution (i.e., a robust model), and (c) an asymmetric Laplace model (i.e., Bayesian quantile regression and an alternative robust model). Based on leave-one-out cross-validation and posterior predictive model checking, we found that both robust models outperformed the Gaussian model, and both robust models performed comparably well. While the Student's t model performed statistically slightly better (yet not substantially so), the asymmetric Laplace model yielded somewhat more realistic posterior predictive samples and a higher degree of measurement precision (i.e., for those estimates that were either associated with the lowest or highest degree of measurement precision). The findings are discussed for the context of learning progress assessment.

The Superiority of Bayes Linear Unbiased Estimation in the Growth Curve Model

The Superiority of the Bayes Linear Unbiased Minimum Variance Estimator under Balanced Loss Function

The Superiority of Bayes Linear Unbiased Minimum Variance Estimator with Respect to Ridge Estimator

A Two-Step Estimation Method for Grouped Data with Connections to the Extended Growth Curve Model and Partial Least Squares Regression.

Bayesian Growth Curve Models with the Generalized Error Distribution

Bayes estimator for the inequality-constrained regression model*

Flexible Bayesian quantile regression for nonlinear mixed effects models based on the generalized asymmetric Laplace distribution

Bayesian Approach to Non-ignorable Missingness in Latent Growth Models

Modeling Error Distributions of Growth Curve Models Through Bayesian Methods.

Comparison of Inverse Wishart and Separation-Strategy Priors for Bayesian Estimation of Covariance Parameter Matrix in Growth Curve Analysis

Small-sample Properties for Generalized Ridge Estimator of Regression Coefficients in Linear Regression Model

Bayesian analysis for nonlinear regression model under skewed errors, with application in growth curves

Evaluation of A Bayesian Approach to Estimating Nonlinear Mixed-Effects Mixture Models

Shaky Student Growth? A Comparison of Robust Bayesian Learning Progress Estimation Methods

Bayesian Analysis Of Longitudinal Data Using Growth Curve Models

Bayesian Inference and Application of Robust Growth Curve Models Using Student'S T Distribution

Bayesian Methods and Model Selection for Latent Growth Curve Models with Missing Data

Efficient Empirical Bayes prediction under check loss using Asymptotic Risk Estimates

A Non-Parametric Shrinkage Mean Estimation for Arbitrary Quadratic Loss Functions and Unknown Covariance Matrices

Non-parametric Shrinkage Mean Estimation for Quadratic Loss Functions with Unknown Covariance Matrices

Model Selection Criteria for Latent Growth Models Using Bayesian Methods