Overconfident Agent's Incentive Mechanisms Based on the Combined Long-term and Short-term Performance
Shi-min SUN,Lin-yu ZHANG,Xi-nan ZHAO,Jian-feng JIA
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-6062.2013.04.020
2013-01-01
Abstract:The current research on overconfident agent's incentive mechanisms is based on net profit and current period performance. However,net profit is only the matching result of whole income and whole expenditure according to accrual basis. Since net profit doesn't include the cost of equity capital,it cannot reflect an enterprise's value creation. Current period performance,also named short-term performance,lies primarily on an agent's short-term effort. In fact,an agent's effort includes not only short-term effort but also long-term effort,such as research development and market development. The contribution of long-term effort may not be able to improve the current period performance. On the contrary,it decreases the current period performance because of investment. It can influence an agent's short-term game behavior. This paper uses value creation as performance measurement standard and designs overconfident agent's incentive model by combining long-term and short-term performance according to current period performance and future performance. This paper uses principal and agent's overconfidence degree and risk preference,tests the incentive effect of compensation contract for agent based on combined long-term and short-term performance,and reveals agent's effort and requirement for surplus share proportion. Important findings are drawn from this study. Firstly,the higher an agent's degree of overconfidence for unfavorable factors,the smaller the required surplus share proportion is,and the lower the working effort level is. Contrary findings can be found for favorable factors. Secondly,the higher the principal's degree of overconfidence degree for unfavorable factors,the bigger the surplus share proportion an agent can receive and the greater an agent's effort is. Contrary findings can be found for favorable factors. Thirdly,the stronger an agent's risk preference,the higher the distribution proportion of long-term and short-term effort is,and the lower an agent's effort is. The stronger a principal's risk preference,the bigger the surplus share proportion of long-term and short-term performance is and the greater an agent's effort is. Fourthly,agents in monopoly industries make less effort than ones in competitive industries. The greater the proportion of monopoly earnings is,the less effort agents make. Therefore,it is necessary to introduce competitive mechanism in monopoly industries or transform monopoly industries to competitive industries in order to motivate agents' enthusiasm.