Abstract:Design optimization without considering uncertainties of system variables and parameters can be problematic in real life. In order to take into account the effect of uncertainties, reliable and robust design schemes have proven effective, but limited studies have been reported to compare their difference in a multiobjective framework. This paper takes a typical vehicle structure subject to offset frontal crashing scenario as an example to compare reliable and robust designs with their deterministic counterpart. The thicknesses of some key components of vehicle frontal structures were selected as design variables, the vehicle weight and energy absorption as the objectives, deceleration and firewall intrusion as the constraints. The deterministic multiobjective optimization problem was first solved by adopting Design of Experimental (DOE), metamodels and Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm II (NSGA-II). Take into account the uncertainties, a Monte Carlo Simulation (MCS) is adopted to generate random distributions of the objective and constraint functions for each design. For the reliability-based optimization the desired reliabilities of 90 %, 95 % and 99 % are considered, respectively. For the robustness-based optimization, two different formulation strategies are adopted. The optimization showed that the reliable and robust Pareto fronts are shifted away from their deterministic counterpart due to uncertainties. The different Pareto fronts yielded from the deterministic, reliable and robust designs are compared to provide some quantitative insights into how to apply these different design schemes for resolving uncertainty problems. It is shown that, compared with the baseline design, the optimizations enhance the crashworthiness of vehicle, though more conservative solutions could have been generated from the reliable and robust optimizations.

Multi-objective Optimization for Crash Safety Design of Vehicles Using Stepwise Regression Model

Crashworthiness Design of Vehicle by Using Multiobjective Robust Optimization

Multi Objective Optimization of Vehicle Crashworthiness Based on Combined Surrogate Models

A Two-Stage Multi-Objective Optimisation Of Vehicle Crashworthiness Under Frontal Impact

A Comparative study on multiobjective reliable and robust optimization for crashworthiness design of vehicle structure

Crashworthiness analysis and multi-objective optimization of a commercial vehicle frame: A mixed meta-modeling-based method

Probability-based least square support vector regression metamodeling technique for crashworthiness optimization problems

Optimisation and Robustness for Crashworthiness of Side Impact

Multivariable Crashworthiness Optimization of Vehicle Body by Unreplicated Saturated Factorial Design

CRASHWORTHINESS SIMULATION DESIGN OPTIMIZATION USING SUCCESSIVE RESPONSE SURFACE METHODOLOGY

Integrating Least Square Support Vector Regression and Mode Pursuing Sampling Optimization for Crashworthiness Design

Multi-Objective Optimization for Structure Crashworthiness Based on Kriging Surrogate Model and Simulated Annealing Algorithm

Frontal Crashworthiness Optimization for a Light-Duty Vehicle Based on a Multi-Objective Reliability Method

Integrated Design Technique for Materials and Structures of Vehicle Body under Crash Safety Considerations

Multi-objective optimization and design considering automotive high-speed and low-speed crashworthiness

A Method for Selecting Surrogate Models in Crashworthiness Optimization

Optimization of Vehicle Crashworthiness Based on Shrinking Space Regression Method

Improved Structural Impact Performance Using Sequential Multiquadric Regression with Output Space Mapping

Time-based Metamodeling Technique for Vehicle Crashworthiness Optimization

Using successive response surface methodology

An Integrated Multi-Objective Optimization Method with Application to Train Crashworthiness Design