Debate Between Boris Porshnev and Roland Mousnier: Its Ins, Outs, and Revelations

GAO Yi
2008-01-01
Abstract:The debate on the nature of the 17th century French society between the Soviet historian Boris Porshnev and his French colleague Roland Mousnier during the 1950s and 1960s,as a fruitful and influential exchange of learning and ideas between Marxist and non-Marxist historians,belonging respectively to eastern and western camps at the period of Cold War,has been highly appreciated among historians abroad,but remained curiously unknown till now in China.This article is a research report of the affair,inspired by the relevant discussions at the colloquium about the exchanges between the Soviet and the French historiographies during the 1920s—1980s,held in Vizille,France,in September 2006,for the purpose of showing the Chinese historians how this unduly neglected historiographical event is significant,not only for the researches of the origins of the French Revolution,but also for the Marxist school of historiography to strengthen its influence in the current world.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?