Abstract:Optimization models typically seek to maximize overall benefit or minimize total cost. Yet fairness is an important element of many practical decisions, and it is much less obvious how to express it mathematically. We provide a critical survey of various schemes that have been proposed for formulating ethics-related criteria, including those that integrate efficiency and fairness concerns. The survey covers inequality measures, Rawlsian maximin and leximax criteria, convex combinations of fairness and efficiency, alpha fairness and proportional fairness (also known as the Nash bargaining solution), Kalai-Smorodinsky bargaining, and recently proposed utility-threshold and fairness-threshold schemes for combining utilitarian with maximin or leximax criteria. The paper also examines group parity metrics that are popular in machine learning. We present what appears to be the best practical approach to formulating each criterion in a linear, nonlinear, or mixed integer programming model. We also survey axiomatic and bargaining derivations of fairness criteria from the social choice literature while taking into account interpersonal comparability of utilities. Finally, we cite relevant philosophical and ethical literature where appropriate.

On Fairness and Efficiency from the Perspective of Identity and Difference

Efficiency and Fairness under Non-Pareto Transition

The New Interpretation of Equity and Efficiency

The Reform of College Entrance Examination： Priority to Fairness or Efficiency

Impacts Of Social Comparison And Fairness Facet Preference On Justice Judgments

EFFICIENCY OF COLLECTIVE ACTIONS UNDER THE VISION OF PUBLIC CHOICE AND ITS INSTITUTIONAL CONNOTATION

On the Interrelationship between Equality and Society

A New View on the Relations between Difference and Contradiction

Discussion of the Relationship between Fairness and Efficiency ——Based on Rawls' “A Theory of Justice”

Coordination Between Efficiency and Fairness:from Ideas to Practice

On Equality of Personality and Differences of Status in Private Law

The Reciprocity of Justice

Some Different Points about the Essay "Thoughts of the Relations among Efficiency, Fairness and Justness"

Social Differences and Equal Rights in Chinese Mode

On Contemporary Construction of Ecological Fairness

The (Im)possibility of fairness

The Difference and Similarity Between Zhuang Zi's Freedom and Satre's Freedom

Fair Development: Theoretical Evolution And Practical Orientation In China

A guide to formulating fairness in an optimization model

On the View of Unifying Efficiency and Equality of Chinese Characteristic

The Realization of Equality in Chinese Traditional Culture