Surprising conversion of nanocomposite hydrogels with high mechanical strength by posttreatment: From a low swelling ratio to an ultrahigh swelling ratio
Wei Zhang,Yang Liu,Meifang Zhu,Yu Zhang,Xiaoli Liu,Hao Yu,Yongmei Jiang,Yanmo Chen,Dirk Kuckling,Hans-Juergen P. Adler
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/pola.21749
2006-01-01
Abstract:A series of Laponite XLS/polyacrylamide nanocomposite hydrogels (S–M gels) have been successfully prepared by in situ polymerization. It has been discovered for the first time that the properties of nanocomposite gels can be modulated by posttreatment; the swelling ratio of the S–M gels increases greatly with heat posttreatment, up to several hundreds times (water/solid) or higher, much more than that of any other reported nanocomposite gels. The improvement is due to the physical structure changes of the S–M gels. Moreover, S–M–T gels (S–M gels after post-treatment) with an ultrahigh swelling ratio still show excellent resilience under pressure, and they can be regarded as novel elastic superabsorbents. Polymer hydrogels attract much scientific interest as special soft and wet materials.1 Hydrogels have been widely used in many fields, such as superabsorbents,2 protein separation,3 molecular filtration,4 and the release of proteins.5 However, conventional polymeric hydrogels crosslinked by organic reagents are always brittle and exhibit weak mechanical properties, and this limits the applications of hydrogels. Therefore, it is necessary to improve the mechanical properties of polymer hydrogels for wider applications. Recently, three novel hydrogels with high mechanical strength have been successfully synthesized: a nanocomposite gel (NC gel),6 a topological gel,7 and a double-network gel.8 NC gels are clay/polymer nanocomposite hydrogels crosslinked by clay platelets without organic crosslinkers. Compared with the other two gels, NC gels have an important advantage: simplicity of synthesis. The mechanical strength of NC gels increases with increasing clay content.9-11 However, most NC gels have been synthesized with low clay contents because of the high viscosity of the aqueous clay dispersion at high clay concentrations. Recently, using Laponite XLS (Clay-S), a kind of synthetic hectorite modified by tetrasodium pyrophosphate, we easily solved this difficulty and successfully prepared high-clay-content Clay-S/poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAAm) nanocomposite hydrogels (S–N gels).12 With this clay, there are many advantages, such as a low solution viscosity at a high clay concentration, a stable clay dispersion in water, and no need for a special mixer and complicated procedure, unlike the preparation of similar NC gels with Laponite XLG.13 Additionally, we have successfully prepared Clay-S/polyacrylamide (PAAm) nanocomposite hydrogels (S–M gels) in a similar way.14 S–M gels show much better resilience, lower elastic hysteresis, and ultrahigh elongation in comparison with S–N gels. Because the network structure of NC gels is noncovalent, essentially different from the covalent network structure of traditional hydrogels crosslinked by organic reagents, the structure and properties of NC gels should be affected by a posttreatment, such as heat, a solvent, or light. In this article, it is surprisingly demonstrated that the swelling ratio of S–M gels increases greatly via heat posttreatment, that is, from 79 g/g for S5M20 (before the treatment) to 861 g/g (after a 20-day treatment at 40 °C), which is much higher than that of any other reported NC gels, whose swelling ratio is no more than 90 g/g.9, 10, 12 The treated S–M gels still sustain high strength and high elongation at break like untreated S–M gels and show excellent elasticity even at ultrahigh swelling ratios. The ultrahigh-swelling S–M gels have wide potential applications, such as novel elastic diapers and mechanical devices. It has been discovered for the first time that the properties of NC gels can be modulated by posttreatment. Furthermore, the effects of posttreatment on the properties of S–M gels will help the further investigation of the structure of NC gels and present a new approach to controlling the properties and structure of NC gels. Acrylamide (AAm; 98.5%, chemically pure; Shanghai Fine Chemical Material Institute), 2-acrylamido-2-methylpropanesulfonic acid (chemically pure; Lubrizol, United States), synthetic hectorite [Clay-S; Rockwood Co., United States; 92.32 wt % Mg5.34Li0.66 Si8O20(OH)4Na0.66 and 7.68 wt % Na4P2O7], N,N′-methylenebisacrylamide (NMBA), potassium persulfate (KPS), and N,N,N′,N′-tetramethyldiamine (TEMED; analytical reagent; Shanghai Chemical Reagent) were used. All reagents were used as received. All solutions used in the experiments were prepared in deionized water. The hydrogels were prepared with initial solutions consisting of a monomer (AAm), a crosslinker (Clay-S or NMBA), an initiator (KPS), and an accelerator (TEMED). In all cases, the water/initiator ratio and the volume of the accelerator were fixed at 1000/1 (w/w) and 24 μL, respectively. First, a transparent aqueous solution consisting of water (28 mL), clay (1.5–3 g) or NMBA (0.015 g), and AAm (3–6 g) was prepared. Then, the accelerator (TEMED, 24 μL) and an aqueous solution of the initiator (KPS; 0.03 g in 2 mL of water) were added to the former solution with stirring at room temperature. Next, free-radical polymerization was carried out at 30 °C for 24 h, and then the gels were treated in an incubator at 40 °C for a period of time (5–20 days). The hydrogels were synthesized and treated in airtight glass tubes (interior size: 5 mm in diameter and 60 mm long). The composition and preparation of the poly(acrylamide-co-2-acrylamido-2-methylpropanesulfonic acid) [P(AAm-co-AMPS)] superabsorbent were the same as those reported in our previous article.15 For the measurements of the swelling ratio and mechanical properties, the hydrogels were used as prepared to retain the same size for all gel samples. In this article, the nanocomposite hydrogels are expressed as SxMyTz, where S, M, and T stand for the Clay-S concentration, PAAm concentration, and treatment time, respectively, and x, y, and z stand for 100 × clay/water (w/w), 100 × monomer/water (w/w), and the days of treatment, respectively. For example, S5M20T20 stands for the gel containing Clay-S with a Clay-S/water ratio of 5/100 (w/w) and PAAm with a polymer/water ratio of 20/100(w/w) and treated for 20 days. A traditional PAAm hydrogel crosslinked by organic reagents (i.e., NMBA) is called an OR–PAAm gel. The infrared spectra of samples, which were freeze-dried for 48 h in a vacuum oven, were taken as KBr pellets with a Nicolet Nexus-670 FTIR spectrophotometer in the range of 500–4000 cm−1. The swelling experiments were performed by the immersion of the as-prepared gels (sample size: 5 mm in diameter and 10 mm long) in a large excess of water (2000 mL) at room temperature to reach the swelling equilibrium, and then the swollen gels were dried. The measurements of the tensile properties were performed on hydrogels of the same size with a Dejie DXLL-20000. The conditions were as follows: temperature, 25 °C; sample size, 5 mm in diameter and 40 mm long; gauge length, 15 mm; and crosshead speed, 100 mm/min. The strain under stress was defined as the change in the length with respect to the initial length of the specimen, and the strength was calculated on the basis of the initial cross section. The FTIR spectra of pure linear PAAm, Clay-S, and S5M20 gels with different treatment times are given in Figure 1. In the FTIR spectra of S5M20T0 [Fig. 1(c)] without treatment, the peaks can be observed at 3188 cm−1, corresponding to the NH stretching of the AAm unit, at 1674 cm−1, corresponding to the carbonyl moiety of the AAm unit, at 1454 cm−1, corresponding to the CN stretching of the AAm unit, and at 1005 cm−1, corresponding to the SiO stretching of clay. These indicate that the prepared S5M20T0 gel had all expected characteristic groups. As shown in Figure 1, the curves of S5M20T0 and S5M20T20 [Fig. 1(c,d)] are almost the same, indicating that the chemical components of the S5M20 gel did not change through a 20-day posttreatment. FTIR spectra of (a) PAAm, (b) Clay-S, (c) S5M20T0, and (d) S5M20T20 samples. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at www.interscience.wiley.com.] Figure 2 shows the effect of the treatment time on the equilibrium swelling ratio of the S–M gels. The equilibrium swelling ratio increases with increasing treatment time. As a rule, the equilibrium swelling ratio of a hydrogel depends on the hydrophilicity of the polymer chains and the physical structure of the hydrogels. Because the FTIR results show that the chemical components of the S–M gels do not change through the posttreatment, a remarkable improvement of the swelling ratio of the S–M gels should result from the change in the physical structure of the hydrogel network. Although the precise nature of the interaction between the polymer and clay is still not very clear, the interaction is generally regarded as a combination of hydrogen bonding and ionic interaction.10, 16 The oxygen atoms of the clay surface may be able to form hydrogen bonds with the amide proton of AAm, and the metal atoms on the clay surface may form a complex with the carboxyl oxygen of AAm. The number of clay platelets in a 100-nm cube (106 nm3) is high, about 20 for 5 g of clay/100 g of water,9, 10, 17 and the clay platelets act as multifunctional crosslinks with an average effective functionality around 50.17 Therefore, it is quite reasonable for a single PAAm chain to interact with different clay platelets and one clay platelet to interact with several repeat units of the same PAAm chain. We presume that some repeat units interacting with clay platelets detached from the clay surface during the heat treatment. Thus, the number of repeat units of every PAAm chain that interact with clay platelets decreases after the heat treatment, and the length of the PAAm chain between neighboring clay platelets increases. This endows hydrogels with a larger swelling potential. As shown in Figure 2, the equilibrium swelling ratio of the S–M gels improved greatly after posttreatment at 40 °C (e.g., from 79 g/g for S5M20 to 861 g/g for S5M20T20). We are systematically investigating the temperature effects on the swelling ratio of S–M gels. The swelling ratio of the S–M gels treated at 80 °C increased more in a shorter treatment time. Moreover, the S5M10 and S10M10 gels almost dissolved in water after the heat treatment at 80 °C for 9 days, verifying the detachment of polymer chains from clay platelets and the damage to the network structure. The detailed effects of the temperature on the equilibrium swelling ratio will be reported in our future publications. Effects of the treatment time on the equilibrium swelling ratio of the S–M gels. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at www.interscience.wiley.com.] In contrast, the equilibrium swelling ratio of the OR–PAAm gels with different treatment times changed little and was much smaller than those of the S–M gels and S–M–T gels, indicating that the structure of the OR–PAAm gels remained almost constant with the heat treatment. This is due to the aforementioned reason: a network of gels crosslinked by covalent bonds is dense, inhomogeneous, and unchangeable, whereas a network of NC gels crosslinked by clay platelets is loose, homogeneous, and changeable by posttreatment. The equilibrium swelling ratios of S–M gels with different PAAm and Clay-S contents are shown in Table 1. The equilibrium swelling ratio of the S–M gels slightly decreased with increasing clay content, whereas it obviously decreased with increasing PAAm content. At the same PAAm content, the equilibrium swelling ratios of the S–M gels or S–M–T gels were almost the same, such as 120 g/g for S5M15 and 106 g/g for S10M15 and 1265 g/g for S5M15T20 and 1300 g/g for S10M15T20. The time dependence of the swelling ratio is given in Figure 3(a). Here, the swelling ratios at 0 h correspond to the initial water contents of the as-prepared S–M–T and OR–PAAm gels. The swelling ratio of the S–M–T gels at all times and at equilibrium decreased with increasing PAAm and Clay-S contents. This was due to the increase in the effective crosslinking density. Compared with that of the S–M–T gels, the swelling ratio of the OR–PAAm gel was much lower because of the aforementioned essential difference between the S–M gels and OR–PAAm gels in the physical structure. The time to reach the equilibrium swollen state was almost the same at about 80 h. (a) Time dependence of the swelling ratio (Q) measured for S–M–T gels with different clay and polymer contents and the OR–PAAm gel [all the original gels were the same size (5 mm in diameter and 10 mm long)] and (b) S5M20T20 gel in different states [dried gel (left, water/solid weight ratio = 0/1), as-prepared gel (middle, water/solid weight ratio = 4/1), and equilibrium swollen gel (right, water/solid weight ratio = 861/1)]. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at www.interscience.wiley.com.] The S5M20T20 gels in different states are shown in Figure 3(b). All the gels exhibited excellent transparency because the clay was exfoliated as nanometer platelets (diameter = 30 nm, thickness = 1 nm) and uniformly dispersed in the aqueous media and the hydrophilicity of PAAm was strong enough to attain good compatibility between the clay/PAAm brush particles and water.14 The volume of the S5M20T20 gels changed greatly, and the radius increased from 5 mm for the as-prepared state to 45 mm for the equilibrium swollen state. In addition, the S5M20T20 gels still supported the original shape at an ultrahigh swelling ratio (i.e., 861 g/g), showing good mechanical strength. S–M gels have excellent resilience and mechanical properties.14 The effect of a 40 °C treatment on the tensile properties is shown in Figure 4(a). The excellent mechanical properties of S–M gels are even improved apparently after posttreatment instead of being damaged; for example, the elongation at break of S5M20 increased from 1814 to 2362%, and the tensile strength increased from 120 to 219 kPa. This result indicates that the posttreatment at 40 °C does not damage the mechanical properties. We presume that although the number of repeat units of PAAm chains that interact with clay platelets decreases, the number of clay platelets that interact with every PAAm chain does not decrease much. Clay platelets act as multifunctional crosslinks in NC gels, and one clay platelet interacts with several repeat units of the same PAAm chain. Hence, the whole number of effective junction points in hydrogels that undertake stress does not decrease much, leading to no damage in the mechanical strength. (a) Tensile properties of the as-prepared S–M gels (S5M20T0, S5M20T20, S10M20T0, and S10M20T20) and (b) photographs of the S5M20T20 gel (left side, water/solid weight ratio = 861/1) and P(AMPS-co-AAm) superabsorbent gel (right side, water/solid weight ratio = 370/1, prepared according to our previous work15) compressed by thumbs. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at www.interscience.wiley.com.] Traditional hydrogels are always brittle and exhibit weak mechanical properties, especially at high swelling ratios, because of the high water content and their inherent defect (inhomogeneous structure), and even they cannot support themselves at high swelling ratios. As shown in Figure 4(b1), a traditional P(AAm-co-AMPS) superabsorbent was broken into irregular shapes by its own weight at a high swelling ratio (i.e., 371 g/g) during the swelling process, but the S5M20T20 gel could still sustain its original shape even at an ultrahigh swelling ratio (i.e., 861 g/g). Moreover, it was surprisingly found that S5M20T20 at an ultrahigh swelling ratio still showed good strength and excellent resilience under pressure, as shown in Figure 4(b2,b3). A traditional P(AAm-co-AMPS) superabsorbent was broken into pieces under pressure. The S–M gels exhibited high strength, ultrahigh elongation, and excellent resilience because of the good flexibility and hydrophilicity of the PAAm chains and homogeneous network structure.14 Despite the ultrahigh water content of the S–M–T gels at equilibrium swelling, the hydrophilicity and flexibility of the PAAm chains and the homogeneous network structure in the S–M–T gels were still similar to those of the S–M gels at a low swelling ratio. Thus, the S–M–T gels at an ultrahigh swelling ratio exhibited better resilience and strength than the traditional polymeric superabsorbent because of the essential difference in the structure, although their mechanical properties were worse than those of the as-prepared S–M–T gels because of the ultrahigh water content. A series of S–M gels have been successfully prepared by in situ polymerization. It has been discovered for the first time that the properties of NC gels can be modulated by posttreatment; the swelling ratio of S–M gels increases greatly by heat posttreatment [e.g., from 79 g/g for S5M20 (before the treatment) to 861 g/g (after 20 days of treatment at 40 °C)], much more than any other reported NC gels. Their mechanical properties are also improved apparently by such treatment; for example, the elongation at break of S5M20 increased from 1814 to 2362%, and the tensile strength increased from 120 to 219 kPa. The experimental results indicate that the improvements in the swelling ratio and mechanical properties are due to the physical structure changes in S–M gels. Moreover, S–M–T gels at an ultrahigh swelling ratio still show excellent resilience under pressure, and they can be regarded as novel elastic superabsorbents. We believe that the finding of the effects of posttreatment on the properties of S–M gels will help us to further investigate the structure of NC gels and present a new approach to controlling the properties and structure of NC gels. We are investigating the relationship of the treatment temperature, swelling ratio, and mechanical properties more systematically, such as the effects of higher treatment temperatures and changes in the stress relaxation. This research is financially supported by the Cultivation Fund of the Key Scientific and Technical Innovation Project of the Ministry of Education of China (704021), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (50473002), the National High-Tech 863 Project (2002AA302616), and the Shanghai Nano Special Projects (0452nm006 and 05nm05005).